Are We Getting Better in Using Nitrogen?: Variations in Nitrogen Use Efficiency of Two Cereal Crops Across the United States

Chaoqun Lu,Jien Zhang,Peiyu Cao,Jerry L. Hatfield

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1029/2019ef001155

2019-08-01

Earth's Future

Abstract:Abstract Spatial variation and temporal trajectory of crop nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) have important implications for nitrogen management and environmental conservation. Previous studies have examined cross‐nation divergences in crop NUE but often overlooked its spatial heterogeneity and cross‐crop differences at subnational scales. We examined the relationship between state‐level NUE and nitrogen fertilizer use for two major fertilizer‐consuming crops, corn and winter wheat, which account for over half of national N fertilizer use in the United States. Since 1970, as N fertilizer use rates have changed, the responses of crop yield and NUE have exhibited large temporal and spatial variations. It is evident that NUE of corn begins to decline when N fertilizer application rate exceeds ~150 kg N ha −1 yr −1 , and that yield response of winter wheat slows down with annual N fertilizer input above ~50 kg N ha −1 yr −1 . State‐level NUE in both crops has risen in recent decades, which could potentially reduce N loss from agricultural production. Across the United States, some major corn‐producing states demonstrate a shift from an increasing trend of NUE during the period 1970 to 1999 to a decreasing trend after 2000, whereas winter wheat‐producing states present an opposite pattern. Furthermore, this study indicates that annual dynamics of N surplus in corn is closely tied with grain yields, while that in winter wheat significantly correlates with N fertilizer input. A larger proportion of N loss would be anticipated if no further increase in corn yield was obtained or fertilizer use kept rising in winter wheat. Plain Language Summary There have been growing concerns about a mismatch between agricultural nitrogen supply and crop nitrogen demand. To reduce nitrogen pollution from cultivation, it is essential to know how nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) of crops has changed over space and time, and how far we are from their potentials. Here we examined the NUE patterns in two major fertilizer‐consuming crops across the United States since 1970. Despite large spatial variations, we found that NUE in corn and winter wheat has improved in recent decades, potentially reducing nitrogen loss. We also identified a turning point of nitrogen fertilizer use rate for each crop, above which NUE begins to decline or yield response slows down. In addition, our study shows that nitrogen demand and supply play different roles between crops in regulating nitrogen surplus.Key Points Responses of yield and N use efficiency to N fertilizer input exhibit different trajectories between corn and winter wheat and vary across the states State‐level NUE of corn and winter wheat has improved in recent decades, but peak NUE occurs at a medium level of N fertilizer input Interannual variations in N surplus at a national scale are closely tied with grain yields in corn and with N fertilizer use rate in winter wheat