Exploring the traditional Chinese diet and its association with health status—a systematic review

Jizhao Niu,Bai Li,Qing Zhang,Ge Chen,Angeliki Papadaki

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/nutrit/nuae013

2024-03-08

Nutrition Reviews

Abstract:Context Increased adherence to a traditional Chinese diet (TCD) could reduce the increasing prevalence of noncommunicable diseases. Currently, there is no consistent definition of the TCD in the literature, and its associations with health outcomes have not yet been identified. Objective This systematic review aimed to assess the definition of the TCD, in the literature, and to evaluate whether the TCD, as described, is associated with health outcomes. Data sources Fourteen databases were searched up to April 25, 2022. Data extraction Three reviewers (in pairs) independently screened and extracted data. A modified risk-of-bias tool was used to assess the quality of the studies assessing the TCD definition; the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale and the Cochrane Risk-of-Bias tool were used to assess the quality of the observational studies and randomized controlled trials assessing associations between the TCD and health outcomes. Data analysis Ninety-nine studies were identified that assessed the TCD definition. In at least 75% of the studies, rice and leafy vegetables were consistently reported as food groups that characterize the TCD; the most frequently cited food items were white rice, spinach, bokchoy, and cabbage. Fish and seafood, pork, and pork products were consistently reported in studies exclusively referring to the TCD consumed in southern China (n = 21 studies), whereas wheat and wheat products were commonly reported in studies focusing on northern China (n = 14 studies). Fifteen studies reported on the quantities of food groups that are characteristic of the TCD, but their findings were inconsistent. Of the 99 studies, 54 assessed associations with health outcomes. The TCD was overall inversely associated with obesity risk and weight gain, while relationships between the TCD and other health outcomes were inconsistent. Conclusion Further studies are needed to determine the quantities of foods consumed in the TCD and to establish a consistent definition for further exploration of the TCD's potential role in preventing non-communicable diseases.

nutrition & dietetics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to address the inconsistency in the definition of Traditional Chinese Diet (TCD) and the unclear association between TCD and health outcomes. Specifically, the research objectives include:

1. **Evaluate the definition of TCD**: Identify common food groups and food items in TCD, as well as their consumption frequency and quantity, through a literature review.
2. **Evaluate the relationship between TCD and health outcomes**: Analyze whether TCD is associated with certain health outcomes (such as obesity, weight gain, etc.) and explore the consistency of these relationships.

The research background points out that with socio-economic transformation, the Chinese diet has gradually become westernized, leading to an increase in the prevalence of non-communicable diseases (NCDs). Therefore, promoting traditional Chinese diet may become an important public health measure to prevent NCDs. However, there is currently diversity in the definition of TCD, making it difficult to establish a clear association between TCD and health outcomes. This systematic review hopes to provide scientific evidence for the definition of TCD and its potential health benefits through a systematic literature review.