Island ecosystem health in the context of human activities with different types and intensities

Yuan Chi,Dahai Liu,Wenxiu Xing,Jing Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.125334

IF: 11.1

2021-01-01

Journal of Cleaner Production

Abstract:Island ecosystem health is the integrative reflection of the states of different components on an island under multiple natural and anthropogenic influences. Evaluating island ecosystem health and identifying anthropogenic influences can provide important references for decision-makers in conserving the island ecosystem. In this study, island ecosystem health was evaluated by integrating three components (vegetation, soil, and landscape) using 12 factors sourced by field investigation and remote sensing. Baseline of the island ecosystem health was determined by ascertaining the natural area and context and eliminating the influences from natural factors. Then, the influences from each of the four typical types of island human activities, namely, building construction, traffic development, farming, and plantation, and the comprehensive influences from all of the four types on island ecosystem health were identified. Twenty-five islands in an important and typical archipelago in northern China were used as the study area. Results indicated that inhabited islands with small areas and uninhabited islands with large areas had good island ecosystem health, and the landscape component contributed most to the spatial variance. Traffic development, building construction, and farming generated negative influences and decreased the island ecosystem health by 28.56%, 23.38%, and 9.31%, respectively. By contrast, plantation increased the island ecosystem health by 17.14%. Overall, the four types of human activities increased the island ecosystem health by 2.74% and 5.91% for the inhabited and uninhabited islands, respectively. Scenario analyses revealed that the quality promotion of each human activity could improve the island ecosystem health more than the scale changes among different human activities. The results can help guide the spatial optimization of island human activities and the evaluation of island carrying capacity.

environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology,engineering, environmental

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problems that this paper attempts to solve include:

1. **How to integrate different factors in the three components of vegetation, soil and landscape to measure the health status of island ecosystems and show their spatial distribution at different scales?**
- By selecting 12 key factors (covering vegetation, soil and landscape) and combining field surveys and remote sensing data, the author constructed a comprehensive assessment framework. These factors include Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), Net Primary Productivity (NPP), Shannon - Wiener Index (\(H'\)), Pielou's Evenness Index (\(E\)), Total Organic Carbon (TOC), Total Nitrogen (TN), Available Phosphorus (AP), Available Potassium (AK), Important Landscape Coverage (ILC), Number of Patches (NP), Total Edge length (TE) and Landscape Isolation Index (LII). The formulas are as follows:
\[
NDVI=\frac{(NIR - Red)}{(NIR + Red)}
\]
\[
NPP = \text{calculated by Carnegie - Ames - Stanford model}
\]
\[
H'=-\sum_{i = 1}^{S}p_i\ln(p_i)
\]
\[
E=\frac{H'}{\ln(S)}
\]

2. **How to determine the baseline of island ecosystem health after eliminating the synergistic effects of natural factors?**
- By identifying the natural areas on the islands and excluding the influence of natural factors, the baseline of island ecosystem health was determined. The specific method is to distinguish the influence of human activities and natural changes by analyzing the natural background (such as geology, climate, etc.).

3. **What is the impact degree of each human activity on the three components of vegetation, soil and landscape and the overall health of island ecosystems? What is the comprehensive impact of all types of human activities?**
- Research shows that transportation development, construction and agriculture have decreased the health of island ecosystems by 28.56%, 23.38% and 9.31% respectively, while afforestation has increased it by 17.14%. Overall, these four typical human activities have increased the ecosystem health of inhabited islands by 2.74% and that of uninhabited islands by 5.91%.

4. **What countermeasures can be proposed to improve the health of island ecosystems based on scenario analysis?**
- Scenario analysis shows that improving the quality of each human activity can improve the health of island ecosystems more than changing the scale of different human activities. The research results are helpful to guide the spatial optimization of human activities on islands and the evaluation of island carrying capacity.

By solving the above problems, this study provides important scientific basis and technical support for the protection of island ecosystems.