Variation of volatile fatty acid oxidation and methane production during the bioaugmentation of anaerobic digestion system: Microbial community analysis revealing the influence of microbial interactions on metabolic pathways

Guanjing Cai,Lixin Zhao,Tao Wang,Nan Lv,Junjie Li,Jing Ning,Xiaofang Pan,Gefu Zhu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142425
2021-02-01
Abstract:<p>Anaerobic digestion (AD) is widely used on waste treatment for its great capability of organic degradation and energy recovery. Accumulation of volatile fatty acids (VFAs) caused by impact loadings often leads to the acidification and failure of AD systems. Bioaugmentation is a promising way to accelerate VFA degradation but the succession of microbial communities usually caused unpredictable consequences. In this study, we used the sludge previously acclimated with VFAs for the bioaugmentation of an acidified anaerobic digestion system and increased the methane yield by 8.03–9.59 times. To see how the succession of microbial communities affected bioaugmentation, dual-chamber devices separated by membrane filters were used to control the interactions between the acidified and acclimated sludges. The experimental group with separated sludges showed significant advantages of VFA consumption (5.5 times less final VFA residue than the control), while the group with mixed sludge produced more methane (4.0 times higher final methane yield than the control). Microbial community analysis further highlighted the great influences of microbial interaction on the differentiation of metabolic pathways. Acetoclastic methanogens from the acclimated sludge acted as the main contributors to pH neutralization and methane production during the early phase of bioaugmentation, and maintained active in the mixed sludge but degenerated in the separated sludges where interactions between sludge microbiotas were limited. Instead, syntrophic butyrate and acetate oxidation coupled with nitrate and sulfate reduction was enriched in the separated sludges, which lowered the methane conversion rate and would cause the failure of bioaugmentation. Our study revealed the importance of microbial interactions and the functionality of enriched microbes, as well as the potential strategies to optimize the durability and efficiency of bioaugmentation.</p>
environmental sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to solve the acidification problem caused by the accumulation of volatile fatty acids (VFAs) in anaerobic digestion systems and restore the function of acidified anaerobic digestion systems through bio - augmentation technology. Specifically, the study explored how the interactions between different microbial communities affect the changes in metabolic pathways, thereby influencing the effectiveness of bio - augmentation. By using VFAs - adapted sludge for bio - augmentation, the study not only increased methane production (by 8.03 - 9.59 times), but also revealed the important influence of microbial community succession on the differentiation of metabolic pathways. The main findings of the study include: 1. **Effectiveness of bio - augmentation**: By adding VFAs - adapted sludge, the recovery efficiency of acidified anaerobic digestion systems was significantly improved, especially in terms of methane production. 2. **Interactions of microbial communities**: The two - chamber device in the experimental design separated the acidified sludge and the adapted sludge, restricting the direct movement of microorganisms but allowing solute exchange. The results showed that the interactions between microorganisms had a significant impact on the differentiation of metabolic pathways. For example, the mixed sludge group degraded butyric acid at a slower rate in the early stage of bio - augmentation, but showed the best performance after 14 days. 3. **Changes in microbial community structure**: High - throughput sequencing analysis showed that the microbial community structure of acidified sludge and adapted sludge changed significantly during the bio - augmentation process. In particular, the numbers of certain key genera such as Methanobacterium and Azospira increased, while the numbers of other genera such as Methanosaeta decreased, indicating a potential shift in the methanogenesis pathway. 4. **Changes in the abundance of functional genes**: The analysis of the abundance of functional genes predicted based on the 16S rRNA gene further confirmed the different contributions of metabolic pathways in different sludges. For example, the abundance of functional genes related to butyric acid and acetic acid oxidation in the adapted sludge group (Sep_R) was significantly higher than that in the acidified sludge group (Sep_L), and these genes were significantly enriched during the bio - augmentation process. In conclusion, this study not only solved the acidification problem caused by the accumulation of VFAs in anaerobic digestion systems, but also deeply explored the interactions between microbial communities and their impacts on metabolic pathways, providing a scientific basis for optimizing bio - augmentation strategies.