A Synergetic Effect of the Integration of Lean, Sustainable Construction Practices and Alliance Contract on Operation Performance in the Indian Construction Industry

Praveenkumar Thaloor Ramesh,Elangovan Nattanmai Swaminathan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16051857
IF: 3.9
2024-02-24
Sustainability
Abstract:By pioneering a comprehensive analysis of lean integration within the construction sector, this research provides novel insights into optimizing project outcomes. The construction industry is generally known for its frequent deadline slip-ups, budget overruns, and issues with upholding proper quality. It is usual practice to integrate different management techniques which are successful in the production industry in order to avoid such issues. Several researchers adopted sustainable construction management, lean management and alliance contract practices individually on construction sites to improve the profit, productivity, quality and transparency of the project. In this study, the synergetic integration of sustainable construction management, lean management and alliance contract practices have been studied. A questionnaire survey was conducted among 345 practitioners, resulting in 309 responses after screening. These respondents, comprising various roles in the AEC sector, provided insights into their experience, project involvement, and business sectors. The study identified 23 factors associated with lean practices, sustainable construction, and alliance contracts, examining their relationships and benefits through Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). The results demonstrate significant effects of lean practice, sustainable construction, and alliance contract factors on the benefits derived from their integration. Measures of reliability and validity affirm the robustness of these relationships. The discussion underscores the benefits of integration, including enhanced efficiency, reduced environmental impact, improved collaboration, shared risk and reward, superior project outcomes, and competitive advantage. Overall, this research elucidates the potential advantages of integrating these methodologies within construction projects.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to explore the synergistic integration effects of Lean Construction, sustainable construction management, and alliance contracts in the Indian construction industry and their impact on operational performance. Specifically, the paper investigates the following points: 1. **Lean Construction Practices**: - Optimize project outcomes by reducing waste, increasing efficiency, and improving quality. - Use tools such as the Last Planner System (LPS) and Value Stream Mapping (VSM) to improve construction processes. 2. **Sustainable Construction Management Practices**: - Reduce environmental impact, such as lowering energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions through recycling and green design. - Improve energy efficiency, use sustainable materials, and implement effective waste management. 3. **Alliance Contracts**: - Share risks and rewards in complex and large projects, promoting collaboration to achieve common goals. - Increase transparency, reduce risks, and quickly resolve disputes. The paper collected feedback from 345 construction industry practitioners (ultimately screening out 309 valid responses) through a questionnaire survey, covering various roles such as consultants, researchers, project managers, and contractors. The study used Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to analyze the relationships between these factors and their impact on project performance. The results show that the synergistic integration of Lean Construction practices, sustainable construction management, and alliance contracts has a significant positive impact on multiple aspects of projects, including increased efficiency, reduced environmental impact, improved collaborative communication, shared risks and rewards, enhanced project outcomes, and increased competitiveness. Overall, the study highlights the potential advantages of integrating these approaches into construction projects.