Mitigating non-genetic resistance to checkpoint inhibition based on multiple states of immune exhaustion

Irina Kareva,Jana L. Gevertz
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41540-024-00336-6
2024-02-09
npj Systems Biology and Applications
Abstract:Abstract Despite the revolutionary impact of immune checkpoint inhibition on cancer therapy, the lack of response in a subset of patients, as well as the emergence of resistance, remain significant challenges. Here we explore the theoretical consequences of the existence of multiple states of immune cell exhaustion on response to checkpoint inhibition therapy. In particular, we consider the emerging understanding that T cells can exist in various states: fully functioning cytotoxic cells, reversibly exhausted cells with minimal cytotoxicity, and terminally exhausted cells. We hypothesize that inflammation augmented by drug activity triggers transitions between these phenotypes, which can lead to non-genetic resistance to checkpoint inhibitors. We introduce a conceptual mathematical model, coupled with a standard 2-compartment pharmacometric (PK) model, that incorporates these mechanisms. Simulations of the model reveal that, within this framework, the emergence of resistance to checkpoint inhibitors can be mitigated through altering the dose and the frequency of administration. Our analysis also reveals that standard PK metrics do not correlate with treatment outcome. However, we do find that levels of inflammation that we assume trigger the transition from the reversibly to terminally exhausted states play a critical role in therapeutic outcome. A simulation of a population that has different values of this transition threshold reveals that while the standard high-dose, low-frequency dosing strategy can be an effective therapeutic design for some, it is likely to fail a significant fraction of the population. Conversely, a metronomic-like strategy that distributes a fixed amount of drug over many doses given close together is predicted to be effective across the entire simulated population, even at a relatively low cumulative drug dose. We also demonstrate that these predictions hold if the transitions between different states of immune cell exhaustion are triggered by prolonged antigen exposure, an alternative mechanism that has been implicated in this process. Our theoretical analyses demonstrate the potential of mitigating resistance to checkpoint inhibitors via dose modulation.
mathematical & computational biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is one of the major challenges encountered by immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) in cancer treatment: the emergence of non - genetic resistance. Although immune checkpoint inhibitors have achieved remarkable success in some cancer treatments, there are still some patients who do not respond to the treatment from the very beginning (primary resistance), or gradually develop resistance during the treatment process (acquired resistance). These problems limit the efficacy and application range of ICIs. Specifically, the paper explores the impact of the existence of multi - state immune cell exhaustion on the response to ICIs. The authors hypothesize that the inflammatory response can trigger the conversion of T cells between different exhaustion states, and these conversions may lead to non - genetic resistance to ICIs. By introducing a conceptual mathematical model and combining it with the standard two - compartment pharmacokinetic (PK) model, the researchers simulated these mechanisms and found that by adjusting the dosage and frequency of administration, the resistance to ICIs can be alleviated. The key questions in the paper are: - **Mechanisms of non - genetic resistance**: Explore how the inflammatory response affects the conversion of T cells between different exhaustion states, thereby leading to resistance to ICIs. - **Impact of dosage and administration frequency**: Through mathematical model simulation, study how different dosages and administration frequencies affect the efficacy of ICIs, especially how to reduce resistance by adjusting the dosage and administration frequency. The main conclusion of the paper is that the traditional high - dose and low - frequency administration strategy may be effective for some patients, but may fail for others. In contrast, a strategy similar to continuous administration (i.e., administering smaller doses of the drug multiple times within a relatively short period of time) may be effective for a broader patient population, even at a relatively low cumulative dose. This finding provides a theoretical basis for optimizing the treatment regimens of ICIs.