Thermodynamic screening of various group contribution methods for estimation of the critical properties and acentric factors of deep eutectic solvents
Mohammad Reza Izadi,Reza Haghbakhsh,Sona Raeissi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molliq.2024.124345
IF: 6
2024-03-05
Journal of Molecular Liquids
Abstract:The Deep Eutectic Solvents (DESs), considering their favorable features, such as low vapor pressure, environmental sustainability, and biodegradability, have gained much attention in the last two decades. However, further development of DESs requires knowledge of their physical and critical properties. Since most DESs thermally decompose before reaching their critical point, their critical properties cannot be measured experimentally. Therefore, theoretical predictive methods, such as group contribution (GC) models are applied. However, up to now, no GC models have been developed specifically for the estimation of DES critical properties. To deal with this issue, almost all of the researchers have applied the modified Lydersen Joback-Reid method developed for Ionic Liquids (ILs), proposed by the group of Valderamma. Since ILs are basically different compounds than DESs, the question remains as to why a model aimed specifically at ILs should be used for DESs. Furthermore, the reliability and extent of accuracy of their application to DESs are unknown. A third question in this area is whether other GC models could be applied to DESs. To investigate these issues, in the present study, six different GC models, namely the Lydersen, Ambrose, Klincewicz-Reid, Joback-Reid, Valderamma-Alvarez and Valderamma-Robles models, were studied for the estimation of the critical properties and acentric factors of a wide variety of DESs. To evaluate the reliability of the investigated GC models, since actual experimental data are not available for these properties, an indirect approach was taken in which the predicted critical properties and acentric factors were used to estimate densities and surface tensions (one volume based and one energy-based parameter), whose experimental data are available for DESs. The results indicated that the Ambrose model, followed by the Valderamma-Alvarez and Valderamma- Robles models, by considering their better performances and the larger variety of DESs that they can handle, are the most globally applicable among all six investigated GC models. Regarding accuracy alone, the model of Ambrose has an edge over the others and is suggested as the most accurate GC model for the estimation of the critical properties and acentric factors of DESs. The Valderamma-Alvarez and Valderamma-Robles models seem to be the next best accurate models. Therefore, the overall results of this study point out that the common approach taken up to this point by almost all researchers to estimate these properties needs to be reconsidered.
chemistry, physical,physics, atomic, molecular & chemical