Machine condition monitoring for defect detection in fused deposition modelling process: a review

Hao He,Zhi Zhu,Yixia Zhang,Zhongpu Zhang,Tosin Famakinwa,Richard Yang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-024-13630-8
IF: 3.563
2024-04-19
The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology
Abstract:Abstract Additive manufacturing (AM), also known as 3D printing (3DP), refers to manufacturing technologies that build up the desired geometries by adding materials layer by layer. Common meltable and fusible materials such as polymers, metals, and ceramics could be used in 3DP processes. During decades of development, products made by 3DP can now achieve stringent industrial standards at comparable costs compared to those traditionally manufactured. Improving 3DP technologies is required to make them more competitive and acceptable than their counterparts. However, achieving this is challenging since the quality of printing products is still heavily dependent on many cost-driven factors. Inadequate quality, impaired functionality, and reduced service life are three main consequences of 3DP’s failures. To effectively detect and mitigate defects and failures of 3DP products, machine condition monitoring (MCM) technologies have been used to monitor 3D printing processes. With the help of those dedicated algorithms, it could also prevent failures from occurrence by alerting operators to take appropriate actions accordingly. This study systematically reviews the MCM technologies used in a typical 3DP process—the fused deposition modelling (FDM), identifying their advantages and disadvantages. The mentioned MCM technologies include but are not limited to traditional MCM (sensors only), aided with analytical and artificial intelligence (AI) tools. The MCM techniques focus on the defects of the 3DP process. The detection and identification of those defects are investigated. Furthermore, research trends on developing MCM technologies, including challenges and opportunities, are identified for improving the FDM process. This review highlights the developed methodologies of MCM that are applied to FDM processes to detect and identify abnormalities such as defects and failures. The evaluations of defects are elaborated to deepen the comprehension of the essence of the defects, including their cause, severity, and effect. A detailed deliberation about identifying the critical components for the successful application of 3DP MCM systems was done. Finally, this review indicates the technical barriers that need to be overcome to enhance the performance of monitoring, detection, and prediction by MCM and associated technologies.
engineering, manufacturing,automation & control systems
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the challenges of defect detection and fault monitoring in 3D printing (3DP), especially in the Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) process. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to improve the quality and reliability of 3D - printed products through Machine Condition Monitoring (MCM) techniques, and reduce the increase in production costs or product abandonment caused by defects and faults. The paper points out that although 3D printing technology shows great potential in the manufacturing field, the quality of its products is still affected by multiple factors, such as material properties, improper setting of process parameters, etc. These factors may cause defects such as rough surfaces, material pores, and body cracks in products, affecting the functionality and service life of the products. Therefore, the paper aims to systematically review and analyze the application of MCM techniques in the FDM process, evaluate the advantages and limitations of these techniques in defect detection and identification, and explore future research directions and the possibility of technological improvement. The paper addresses the above problems in the following aspects: 1. **Systematic review of MCM techniques**: Classify and evaluate existing MCM techniques, including traditional sensor monitoring techniques and advanced MCM techniques combined with analytical tools and artificial intelligence (AI). 2. **Defect detection and identification**: Discuss in detail the common defect types and their causes in the FDM process, and introduce the methods and techniques used to detect and identify these defects. 3. **Research trends and challenges**: Analyze the development trends of MCM techniques in the 3D printing field, and point out the current technical obstacles and future research opportunities. 4. **Methodology review**: Provide the application methodology of MCM techniques in the FDM process, including data collection, selection criteria for processing algorithms, etc. Through these contents, the paper aims to provide a comprehensive reference for researchers and the industry to promote the further development and application of 3D printing technology.