Abstract:Context Educational reform efforts have taken the form of different school models intended to reduce educational inequality. Personalized, interest-based schools and academically focused, “No Excuses” schools are two leading small-school designs with sharply contrasting approaches to innovation. Given mixed research findings about the successes and challenges of school reform models in the United States, it is imperative to understand how educational outcomes of students relate to the philosophy and distinguishing characteristics of particular school models such as these. At the same time, evaluating social mobility effects of high school education across educational reform models requires examination of common metrics such as high school graduation rate and college entrance and degree attainment. Purpose This study sought to establish whether and how a personalized, interest-based secondary school reform model is associated with graduates’ characteristics and postsecondary outcomes—and to place these findings in relation to student outcomes reported by a leading No Excuses school network. Setting Big Picture Learning is a network of innovative small schools that serves primarily low-income and minoritized students through an individualized, relational, real-world-based high school experience. The Big Picture educational model features individualized learning plans connected to extensive internships, independent learning organized around student interests, authentic assessments, and close, informal relationships between students and adults. Research Design The Big Picture Longitudinal Study tracked 1900 graduates from six graduating high school classes. Data sources included student and school advisor surveys, National Student Clearinghouse college enrollment data, and interviews with graduates’ former advisors. Published outcomes data for KIPP No Excuses schools provided comparative information. Analyses comprised descriptive statistics of survey data and multivariate regression analyses connecting high school exit data to college outcomes. Findings The Big Picture Learning model is extremely successful in meeting its stated goals of fostering positive relationships, helping students discover and pursue their interests, and promoting high school graduation and college entrance. Results for academic subject achievement and college persistence are mixed, however. Big Picture graduates have similar college matriculation rates but somewhat lower six-year graduation rates than alumni from the KIPP No Excuses school network. Alumni from both networks show high rates of college attrition. Conclusion When taken alone and in context of other innovative school models, the Big Picture results point to the difficulty of sustaining secondary school gains in the post-high school lives of low-income students and highlight shortcomings of traditional colleges in serving this population.

Effects of Information, Guidance, and Actions on Postsecondary Destinations: A Study of Talent Loss

Effects of Information, Guidance, and Actions on Postsecondary Destinations: A Study of Talent Loss

The role of psychological factors and institutional channels in predicting the attainment of postsecondary goals.

Why test? Talent loss and enrollment loss

A Broken Pipeline: Effects of Gender and Racial/Ethnic Barriers on College Students’ Educational Aspiration–Pursuit Gap

Understanding factors that influence students' sense of belonging and engagement in a career exploration program: A mixed methods study

Science and engineering degree attainment of aspiring-scientists in the United States

What Boosts Talent Development? Examining Predictors of Academic Growth in Secondary School Among Academically Advanced Youth Across 21 Years

First-generation student pathways to persistence and degree attainment: The roles of deeper learning and self-regulated learning beliefs

Predicting change over time in career planning and career exploration for high school students

Retained for life: A longitudinal study on the effects of grade retention in secondary education on higher education enrollment and self-efficacy

Student Characteristics, Institutional Factors, and Outcomes in Higher Education and Beyond: An Analysis of Standardized Test Scores and Other Factors at the Institutional Level with School Rankings and Salary

Supplementary Education at College and Its Consequences for Individuals’ Labor Market Outcomes in the United States

Academic Success for Students in Postsecondary Education: The Role of Student Characteristics and Integration

Student Retention: An Integrated Application of the Theory of Planned Behavior and the Campus Social Environment

The Role of Dual Enrollment STEM Coursework in Increasing STEM Career Interest among American High School Students

Where to Go From Here? Toward a Model of 2-Year College Students’ Postsecondary Pathway Selection

Exploring the role of socioeconomic status and psychological characteristics on talent development in an English soccer academy

Effects of International Student Mobility on Post-Graduation Decisions: Evidence from Chinese Academic and Vocational Graduates

Postsecondary Outcomes of Innovative High Schools: The Big Picture Longitudinal Study

Unequal expectations? Testing decisional mechanisms for secondary effects of social origin