The challenge of ecological validity in temporomandibular disorders research

Jeffrey C. Nickel,Yoly M. Gonzalez,Luigi M. Gallo,Laura R. Iwasaki
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/joor.13707
2024-04-27
Journal of Oral Rehabilitation
Abstract:Current approaches used to study temporomandibular disorders in terms of neuromechanics, masticatory muscle behaviors, and the dynamics of the autonomic nervous system were assessed for quantitative and ecological validity in this review. Findings suggests that subjective means of measuring behavior does not correlate with objectively acquired data. Future human research which focuses on temporomandibular disorders require experimental designs with ecological validity that capture objectively measured data which meaningfully reflect circadian and ultradian states. Objective To review the ecological validity of outcomes from current research involving temporomandibular disorders (TMDs), with an emphasis on chronic myofascial pain and the precocious development of degenerative disease of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ). Materials and Methods Current approaches used to study TMDs in terms of neuromechanics, masticatory muscle behaviours, and the dynamics of the autonomic nervous system (ANS) were assessed for ecological validity in this review. In particular, the available literature was scrutinized regarding the effects of sampling, environmental and psychophysiological constraints and averaging data across biological rhythms. Results Validated computer‐assisted numerical modelling of the neuromechanics used biological objective functions to accurately predict muscle activation patterns for jaw‐loading tasks that were individual‐specific. With respect to masticatory muscle behaviour, current findings refute the premise that sustained bruxing and clenching at high jaw‐loading magnitudes were associated with painful TMDs such as myofascial pain. Concerning the role of the ANS in TMDs, there remains the need for personalized assessments based on biorhythms, and where the detection of dysregulated physiologic oscillators may inform interventions to relieve pain and restore normal function. Conclusions Future human research which focuses on TMD myofascial pain or the precocious development and progression of TMJ degenerative joint disease requires experimental designs with ecological validity that capture objectively measured data which meaningfully reflect circadian and ultradian states.
dentistry, oral surgery & medicine
What problem does this paper attempt to address?