When I use a word . . . Fictional drugs and the benefit to harm balance

Jeffrey K Aronson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q1814

2024-08-18

BMJ

Abstract:Benefits and harmsThe use of any therapeutic intervention should involve a calculation of the benefit to harm balance, which has three aspects:1. The possible benefits Benefits do not necessarily accrue when an intervention is introduced, and there is no way of predicting in advance in an individual whether benefits will occur and, if so, to what extent, even if there is an average expectation from the results of clinical trials. Likewise, there is no single word that describes a condition present in the individual that can predict a benefit with some probability, for example genetic variants of tumour proteins.2. The possible harms Similarly, harms do not necessarily occur after the introduction of an intervention. However, in contrast to benefits, there is a word for a condition that can result in a harm with some probability; it is called a hazard. Use of a pharmacological intervention, for example, itself constitutes a...

medicine, general & internal