Abstract:The use of virtual reality (VR) in firefighter training is promising because it provides cost-effective, safe environments that arouse similar behavioral responses to real-life scenarios. However, the pedagogical potential of VR and its impact on learning outcomes compared to traditional methods is currently an under-explored area. This research investigates how well VR can support learning compared to traditional methods in the context of training firefighters in combating vegetation fires. A VR learning environment was developed, informed by a “design for learning” framework providing a pedagogical underpinning. A between-subjects experiment was conducted with 40 participants to measure the knowledge transfer of the VR learning environment against the official textbook. In addition, VR's theorized learning benefits of intrinsic motivation, situational interest, and self-efficacy were compared with textbook-based learning. Lastly, the design quality of the learning environment was assessed based on its learning and user experience. We employed a primarily quantitative approach to data collection and analysis, using a combination of knowledge test results and questionnaires, with supporting qualitative data from semi-structured interviews and observation notes to answer our hypotheses. The results found a significant difference between the knowledge transfer of both conditions, with textbook-based learning more effectively transferring factual and conceptual knowledge than VR. No significant difference was found in reported self-efficacy between the two conditions but was found in reported levels of intrinsic motivation and situational interest, which were higher in the VR condition. The design was found to have facilitated a good user and learning experience, assessed via questionnaire responses. During interviews, VR participants reported high levels of satisfaction with the experience, praising the hands-on learning approach and interactivity, while reporting frustration with the lack of knowledge reinforcement and initial difficulties with the controls. A key finding was that presence was found to be negatively associated with knowledge transfer, which we theorize to be caused by the novelty of the realistic VR environment distracting participants from the more familiar lesson content. This research contributes to the body of work related to knowledge transfer within VR in this domain while highlighting key pedagogical and design considerations that can be used to inform future design implementations.

Optical see-through augmented reality fire safety training for building occupants

Development of an Education and Training System Based on Augmented Reality to Improve the Firefighting Facility Maintenance Ability of Fire Safety Managers

Evaluation of augmented reality technology for the design of an evacuation training game

Development of BIM, IoT and AR/VR technologies for fire safety and upskilling

Enhancing Fire Safety Education Through Immersive Virtual Reality Training with Serious Gaming and Haptic Feedback

Immersive Virtual Reality Serious Games With DL-Assisted Learning in High-Rise Fire Evacuation on Fire Safety Training and Research

A Virtual Reality Based Fire Training Simulator with Smoke Hazard Assessment Capacity

Examining the Role of Augmented Reality and Virtual Reality in Safety Training

Virtual reality for fire safety training: study of factors involved in immersive learning

Design and assessment of a virtual reality learning environment for firefighters

An AR-based safety training assistant in disaster for children

VR training program for fire escape: Learning progress predicted by the perception of fire presence, VR operational frustration, and gameplay self-efficacy

Does your team know how to respond safely to an operating room fire? Outcomes of a virtual reality, AI-enhanced simulation training

The Effect of Fire Training Given with Virtual Reality Applications on Individual Awareness

A real-time fire evacuation system based on the integration of Building Information Modeling and Augmented Reality

Exploring the Design Space of Optical See-through AR Head-Mounted Displays to Support First Responders in the Field

Immersive virtual reality-based training improves response in a simulated operating room fire scenario

Does Augmented Reality Help in Industrial Training? A Comprehensive Evaluation Based on Natural Human Behavior and Knowledge Retention

Design and implementation of fire safety education system on campus based on virtual reality technology

Usability of Immersive Technology for Education and Training of Firefighters in Brazil

Immersive Virtual Reality (IVR) Systems for Comprehensive Fire Safety Education in Primary School