Abstract:Designers and researchers who work with animals need to employ an array of ethical competencies to guarantee the welfare of animals taking part in animal-centered research. The emerging field of Animal-Computer Interaction (ACI), which deals with the design of animal-centered interactive systems, considers ethics a fundamental concern when working with animals, and ACI researchers have proposed ethics frameworks in response to these concerns. Ethical approaches proposed within the field tend to be normative but, on their own, norms may not be sufficient to support designers who will inevitably face unexpected and ethically charged situations as the research progresses. During a research project, focused on the design of dog-friendly controls for Mobility Assistance Dogs (MADs), these limitations came to the fore. Drawing from situated ethics approaches, developed to support researchers' ethical engagement with vulnerable populations such as children and differently abled adults, this paper presents an ethics toolkit that aims to support animal-centered research and design by enabling researchers to make ethically sound situated decisions as their work progresses. The toolkit comprises three templates, each of which asks a series of questions aiming to articulate the ethical baselines of individual team members and of their research project, and to inform the development of a series of ethical guiding statements to better prepare designers to make ethical situated decisions. The application of the toolkit during the research with MADs helped the field researcher to clearly and systematically articulate the project's ethos and understand the ethical stance that guided the research team's interactions with the dogs, their trainers, and their human partners throughout the project. It also fostered a practice of active reflection within the team, which helped them to maintain their commitment to the project's ethos in the face of unexpected ethical challenges. We propose that, beyond supporting ACI research, the toolkit could support the ethical engagement of researchers and practitioners who work for and with animals in many other settings.

Relevance, Impartiality, Welfare and Consent: Principles of an Animal-Centered Research Ethics

3Rs missing: animal research without scientific value is unethical

Considering aspects of the 3Rs principles within experimental animal biology

Beyond Anthropocentrism: The Moral and Strategic Philosophy behind Russell and Burch's 3Rs in Animal Experimentation

Principles of Animal Research Ethics

Internal consistency and compatibility of the 3Rs and 3Vs principles for project evaluation of animal research

The ‘R’ principles in laboratory animal experiments

The Interpretation and Application of the Three Rs by Animal Ethics Committee Members

It’s Time to Review the Three Rs, to Make them More Fit for Purpose in the 21st Century

Interdisciplinary Animal Research Ethics-Challenges, Opportunities, and Perspectives

An Ethics Toolkit to Support Animal-Centered Research and Design

The Role of the Three Rs in Improving the Planning and Reproducibility of Animal Experiments

An international perspective on ethics approval in animal behaviour and welfare research

Status assessment and opportunities for improving fish welfare in animal experimental research according to the 3R-Guidelines

Perceptions of 3R implementation in European animal research: A systematic review, meta-analysis, and meta-synthesis of barriers and facilitators

A case for integrity: gains from including more than animal welfare in animal ethics committee deliberations

One R or the other - an experimental bioethics approach to 3R dilemmas in animal research

Experimental Animal Welfare

Rethinking Animal Consciousness Research to Prioritize Well-Being

Endeavours made by trade associations, pharmaceutical companies and regulators in the replacement, reduction and refinement of animal experimentation in safety testing of pharmaceuticals

Introducing individual sentience profiles in nonhuman primate neuroscience research