Abstract:Macrophages are phagocytic innate immune cells capable of phenotypical switching in response to the local microenvironment. Studies often use either primary macrophages or immortalized cell lines for hypothesis testing, therapeutic assessment, and biomaterial evaluation without carefully considering the potential effects of cell source and tissue of origin, which strongly influence macrophage response. Surprisingly, limited information is available about how, under similar stimuli, immortalized cell lines and primary cells respond in both phenotypical and functional changes. To address this need, in this work, we cultured immortalized macrophage cell lines derived from different origins ( i.e., blood, lung, peritoneal) to understand and compare macrophage phenotypical responses, including polarization and plasticity, morphological changes, and phagocytic functionalities, as well as compared primary macrophages extracted from peritoneal and bone marrow to their immortalized cell line counterparts. We found significant differences in baseline expression of different markers (e.g., CD86, MHCII, CD206, and EGR2) amongst different cell lines, which further influence both polarization and repolarization of the cells, in addition to their phagocytic functionality. Additionally, we observed that, while RAW 264.7 cells behave similarly to the primary bone marrow-derived macrophages, there are noticeable phenotypical and functional differences in cell line (IC-21) and primary peritoneal macrophages, highlighting tissue-specific differences in macrophage response amongst cell lines and primary cells. Moving to three-dimensional (3D) culture in well-defined biomaterials, blood-derived primary and cell line macrophages were encapsulated within hydrogel-based synthetic extracellular matrices and their polarization profiles and cell morphologies were compared. Macrophages exhibited less pronounced polarization during 3D culture in these compliant, soft materials compared to two-dimensional (2D) culture on rigid, tissue culture plastic plates. Overall, our findings highlight origin-specific differences in macrophage response, and therefore, careful considerations must be made to identify the appropriate cell source for the application of interest.

Mimicking the cellular environment does not cause monocyte‐derived macrophages to become phenotypically similar to Kupffer cells

Comparative Analysis of the Transcriptome, Proteome, and miRNA Profile of Kupffer Cells and Monocytes

Bone Marrow-Derived Monocytes Give Rise to Self-Renewing and Fully Differentiated Kupffer Cells

Availability of an inflammatory macrophage niche drives phenotypic and functional alterations in Kupffer cells

A Conserved Pathway of Transdifferentiation in Murine Kupffer Cells

Fetal monocytes possess increased metabolic capacity and replace primitive macrophages in tissue macrophage development

Defining murine monocyte differentiation into colonic and ileal macrophages

A subset of Kupffer cells regulates metabolism through the expression of CD36

Kupffer cell restoration after partial hepatectomy is mainly driven by local cell proliferation in IL-6-dependent autocrine and paracrine manners

In-Depth Proteomic Analysis Reveals Phenotypic Diversity of Macrophages in Liver Fibrosis

Macrophage variance: investigating how macrophage origin influences responses to soluble and physical cues with immortalized vs. primary cells in 2D and 3D culture

Coordinated chemokine expression defines macrophage subsets across tissues

Differential gene expression in human, murine, and cell line-derived macrophages upon polarization

CD49a Expression Identifies a Subset of Intrahepatic Macrophages in Humans.

Hepatocytes reprogram liver macrophages involving control of TGF-β activation, influencing liver regeneration and injury

The macrophage heterogeneity: difference between mouse peritoneal exudate and splenic F4/80+ macrophages.

Differential effects of macrophage subtype‐specific cytokines on fibroblast proliferation and endothelial cell function in co‐culture system

Early-Derived Murine Macrophages Temporarily Renounce Tissue Identity during Acute Systemic Inflammation

Liver Myofibroblasts Regulate the Phenotype and Function of Monocytes Through Soluble Factors in Cirrhosis.

A method to differentiate chicken monocytes into macrophages with proinflammatory properties

Co-stimulation with opposing macrophage polarization cues leads to orthogonal secretion programs in individual cells