Detection of rare and possibly carcinogenic human papillomavirus genotypes as single infections in invasive cervical cancer
Daan Geraets,Laia Alemany,Nuria Guimera,Silvia de Sanjose,Maurits de Koning,Anco Molijn,David Jenkins,Xavier Bosch,Wim Quint,RIS HPV TT Study Group,Doudja Hammouda,Anissa Bouhadef,Nafissa Hamoud,Silvio Alejandro Tatti,Susana Vighi,Suzanne M Garland,Sepher Tabrizi,Ashrafun Nessa,Nahar Rahman,Faruk Ahmed,Mohammad Kamal,Ermina Iljazovic,Marcus Aurelho de Lima,Sérgio Henrique,Rodrigo Prado,Ximena Rodriguez,Marisol Guerrero,Virginia Leiva,Elsa Olave,Claudia Ramis,Viviana Toro,Lin Qiao,Chen Wen,Wu Su Hui,Hector Jaime Posso,Luis Eduardo Bravo,Tito Collazos,Luz Stella García,Raúl Murillo,Gustavo Adolfo Hernández Suárez,Carlos Eduardo Pinzón,Gloria I Sánchez,Magdalena Grce,Ivan Sabol,Sonja Dzebro,Mara Dominis,Ivo Steiner,Hradec Kralove,Vladimir Vonka,Christine Clavel,Massimo Tommasino,Maria Tzardi,Theodoros Agorastos,Luis Estuardo Lombardi,Edgar Kestler,Obdulia Salic,Sergio Marroquin,Victor Argueta,Walter Guerra,Hesler Morales,Annabelle Ferrera,Ricardo Bulnes,Asha Jain,Sushil K Giri,Maheep Bhalla,Bharat Patel,Luciano Mariani,Ferdinando Marandino,Jacob Bornstein,Alejandro Livoff,Hector Itzhac Cohen,Toshiyuki Sasagawa,Shintaro Terahata,Kazuhisa Ishi,Hai-Rim Shin,Jin-Kyoung Oh,Jung-I I Suh,Seo-Hee Rha,Waleed Fahad Al-Jassar,Rema'a Al-Safi,Muhieddine Seoud,Patricia Alonso de Ruiz,Gustavo Lastra,Alma Karina Olivares Montano,Clara Menéndez,Cleofé Romagosa,Carla Carrillo,Adekunbiola Banjo,Rose Anorlu,Fatimah B Abdulkareem,A O Daramola,C C Anunobi,Elena Kasamatsu,Francisco Perrota,Carlos Santos,Eduardo Cáceres,Henry Gómez,Juvenal Sánchez,Carlos S Vallejos,Efren J Domingo,María Julieta V Germar,Jericho Thaddeus P Luna,Carolyn Zalameda-Castro,Arnold M Fernandez,Roslyn Balacuit,Cecilia Ladines Llave,Jean Anne Toral,Andrzej Marcin Nowakowski,Eugenia Cruz,Manuela Lacerda,Manuel Sobrinho-Simoes,Ana Felix,Enrique Lerma,Antonio Llombart-Bosch,Morelva Toro de Méndez,Belen Lloveras,Ana Puras Gil,Miguel Andújar,Jaume Ordi,Adela Pelayo,Julio Velasco,Cristina Pérez,Maria Alejo,Ignacio G Bravo,F Xavier Bosch,Vanesa Camón,Gabriel Capellà,Cristina Caupena,Xavier Castellsagué,Omar Clavero,Silvia de Sanjosé,Mireia Diaz,Ana Esteban,Rebeca Font,Jose M Godínez,Nuria Guimerà,Yolanda Florencia,Helena Frayle,Mercedes Hurtado,Ellen Klaustermeier,Anna Merchán,Carles Miralles,Nuria Monfulleda,Nubia Muñoz,Bea Quirós Cristina Rajo,Sara Tous,Marleny Vergara,August Vidal,Chou Cheng-Yang,Tang-Yuan Chu,Kuo-Feng Huang,Cheng Wen-Fang,Chih-Ming Ho,Saibua C Bunnag Chichareon,Kobkul Tungsinmunkong,Jintamard Suwanjarat,Chris J L M Meijer,Peter J F Snijders,Wim G V Quint,Jean-Paul Brunsveld,Anco C Molijn,Daan T Geraets,Alp Usubutun,Michael Odida,Elisabete Weiderpass,Samfunded Folkhalsan,Esther Oliva,Thomas C Wright,Enrique López Loyo,Victoria García Barriola,Mirian Naranjo de Gómez,Adayza Figueredo,Janira Navarro
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/path.4065
Abstract:The contribution of carcinogenic human papillomavirus (HPV) types to the burden of cervical cancer has been well established. However, the role and contribution of phylogenetically related HPV genotypes and rare variants remains uncertain. In a recent global study of 8977 HPV-positive invasive cervical carcinomas (ICCs), the genotype remained unidentified in 3.7% by the HPV SPF10 PCR-DEIA-LiPA25 (version 1) algorithm. The 331 ICC specimens with unknown genotype were analysed by a novel sequence methodology, using multiple selected short regions in L1. This demonstrated HPV genotypes that have infrequently or never been detected in ICC, ie HPV26, 30, 61, 67, 68, 69, 73 and 82, and rare variants of HPV16, 18, 26, 30, 34, 39, 56, 67, 68, 69, 82 and 91. These are not identified individually by LiPA25 and only to some extent by other HPV genotyping assays. Most identified genotypes have a close phylogenetic relationship with established carcinogenic HPVs and have been classified as possibly carcinogenic by IARC. Except for HPV85, all genotypes in α-species 5, 6, 7, 9 and 11 were encountered as single infections in ICCs. These species of established and possibly carcinogenic HPV types form an evolutionary clade. We have shown that the possibly carcinogenic types were detected only in squamous cell carcinomas, which were often keratinizing and diagnosed at a relatively higher mean age (55.3 years) than those associated with established carcinogenic types (50.9 years). The individual frequency of the possibly carcinogenic types in ICCs is low, but together they are associated with 2.25% of the 8338 included ICCs with a single HPV type. This fraction is greater than seven of the established carcinogenic types individually. This study provides evidence that possibly carcinogenic HPV types occur as single infections in invasive cervical cancer, strengthening the circumstantial evidence of a carcinogenic role.