Critical appraisal of TNM versus HKU staging system for postoperative prognostic evaluation of hepatocellular carcinoma
Wong Hoi She,Albert C. Y. Chan,Ka Wing,Chiu Dai,Kenneth S. H. Chok,Tan To Cheung,Chung Mau Lo,Ka Wing Ma,Wing Chiu Dai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.21037/atm-20-7611
IF: 3.616
2021-06-01
Annals of Translational Medicine
Abstract:BACKGROUND: The 8<sup>th</sup> edition of the American Joint Committee on Cancer tumor-node-metastasis staging system (AJCC 8<sup>th</sup>) has been launched with modifications in T staging. The University of Hong Kong liver cancer staging system (HKUSS) has been proven to better categorize hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) into different T stages. This study aimed to compare the two systems' predictive ability for HCC recurrence after primary surgical resection.METHODS: Patients who had primary, curative resection for HCC between 1989 and 2017 were reviewed. The Kaplan-Meier plot was used to estimate disease-free survival (DFS), and the log-rank test was used for survival comparison between subgroups. The two systems' prediction of recurrence was evaluated by the Cox regression model.RESULTS: Totally 1,815 patients were included. With AJCC 8<sup>th</sup>, the 5-year DFS was 58.9% for T1a, 52.3% for T1b, 30% for T2, 16.9% for T3, and 14.4% for T4. No survival difference was demonstrated between T1a and T1b (P=0.668) or between T3 and T4 (P=0.562). With HKUSS, the 5-year DFS was 57.7% for T1, 43.4% for T2, 28.9% for T3, and 15.7% for T4. The T staging in HKUSS showed significant survival differences (T1 <i>vs.</i> T2, T2 <i>vs.</i> T3, and T3 <i>vs.</i> T4; P<0.001). Using receiver operating characteristic curves to show the recurrence status in the two systems, HKUSS had the largest area under curve (AUC) (HKUSS: AUC =0.655, SE 0.014, P<0.001, 95% CI, 0.628-0.681; AJCC 8<sup>th</sup>: AUC =0.652, SE 0.013, P<0.001, 95% CI, 0.625-0.677).CONCLUSIONS: HKUSS showed better categorization of HCC. In the context of primary surgical resection, HKUSS may be more appropriate for stratification of patients with HCC with various T stages, and thus the choice of staging system when primary surgical resection is considered for patients of HCC.
oncology,medicine, research & experimental