Abstract:Behaviours inferred from telemetry data using hidden Markov models (HMMs) are not typically validated due to difficulty obtaining 'ground truth' behavioural information. Our study is unique in that we investigate the accuracy of HMM‐inferred behaviours by considering movement (visual tracks) and observed behavioural data sets recorded at the same time frequency provided by Joint Nature Conservation Committee. We show that HMMs fitted to tracking data can accurately identify important conservation‐relevant behaviours. Understanding animal movement and behaviour can aid spatial planning and inform conservation management. However, it is difficult to directly observe behaviours in remote and hostile terrain such as the marine environment. Different underlying states can be identified from telemetry data using hidden Markov models (HMMs). The inferred states are subsequently associated with different behaviours, using ecological knowledge of the species. However, the inferred behaviours are not typically validated due to difficulty obtaining 'ground truth' behavioural information. We investigate the accuracy of inferred behaviours by considering a unique data set provided by Joint Nature Conservation Committee. The data consist of simultaneous proxy movement tracks of the boat (defined as visual tracks as birds are followed by eye) and seabird behaviour obtained by observers on the boat. We demonstrate that visual tracking data is suitable for our study. Accuracy of HMMs ranging from 71% to 87% during chick‐rearing and 54% to 70% during incubation was generally insensitive to model choice, even when AIC values varied substantially across different models. Finally, we show that for foraging, a state of primary interest for conservation purposes, identified missed foraging bouts lasted for only a few seconds. We conclude that HMMs fitted to tracking data have the potential to accurately identify important conservation‐relevant behaviours, demonstrated by a comparison in which visual tracking data provide a 'gold standard' of manually classified behaviours to validate against. Confidence in using HMMs for behavioural inference should increase as a result of these findings, but future work is needed to assess the generalisability of the results, and we recommend that, wherever feasible, validation data be collected alongside GPS tracking data to validate model performance. This work has important implications for animal conservation, where the size and location of protected areas are often informed by behaviours identified using HMMs fitted to movement data.

Validating hidden Markov models for seabird behavioural inference

A hidden Markov movement model for rapidly identifying behavioral states from animal tracks

A comparison of techniques for classifying behavior from accelerometers for two species of seabird

The use of an unsupervised learning approach for characterizing latent behaviors in accelerometer data

Analysing detection gaps in acoustic telemetry data to infer differential movement patterns in fish

Estimation and simulation of foraging trips in land-based marine predators

Classifying grey seal behaviour in relation to environmental variability and commercial fishing activity - a multivariate hidden Markov model

Incorporating telemetry information into capture‐recapture analyses improves precision and accuracy of abundance estimates given spatiotemporally biased recapture effort

A novel process to infer the reliability of ecological information derived from passive acoustic telemetry track reconstruction

Hidden Markov Models: Pitfalls and Opportunities in Ecology

A multivariate mixed hidden Markov model to analyze blue whale diving behaviour during controlled sound exposures

Using piecewise regression to identify biological phenomena in biotelemetry datasets

Multi-scale modeling of animal movement and general behavior data using hidden Markov models with hierarchical structures

Validation of an automated data collection method for quantifying social networks in collective behaviours

Uncovering ecological state dynamics with hidden Markov models

Use of bird-borne radar to examine shearwater interactions with legal and illegal fisheries

A review of statistical models used to characterize species-habitat associations with animal movement data

Movement responses to environment: fast inference of variation among southern elephant seals with a mixed effects model

The efficiency of detecting seabird behaviour from movement patterns: the effect of sampling frequency on inferring movement metrics in Procellariiformes

Estimating survival of an anadromous salmonid using Bayesian hierarchical models applied to acoustic telemetry, biological, and environmental data

Changing measurements or changing movements? Sampling scale and movement model identifiability across generations of biologging technology