Veterinary antibiotics and estrogen hormones in manures from concentrated animal feedlots and their potential ecological risks

Cheng Li,Yang Li,Xinyu Li,Xupu Ma,Shuhua Ru,Tianlei Qiu,Anxiang Lu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2020.110463
IF: 8.3
2021-07-01
Environmental Research
Abstract:The spread of pharmaceutically active chemicals (PACs), such as antibiotics and estrogenic hormones from animal manures can pose threats to the ecologic environment. In this work, animal manure samples were collected from 71 concentrated animal feedlots in Northern China and investigated for 24 antibiotics and 4 estrogenic hormones. Results showed that these micropollutants were ubiquitous in manures with the concentration ranges of undetectable (ND)-543,445 μg/kg (mean: 44,568 μg/kg) for antibiotics and ND-249.8 μg/kg (mean: 24.78 μg/kg) for estrogens. There was a significant variation in the amounts of PACs in different animal manures. The amounts of antibiotics in manures had following order: swine (83,177 μg/kg) >chicken (52,932 μg/kg) >beef (37,120 μg/kg) >dairy (305 μg/kg), while the estrogens in dairy (mean: 39.27 μg/kg) and chicken manures (mean: 40.08 μg/kg) were higher than those in beef (2.7 μg/kg) and swine manures (1.8 μg/kg). Based on the estimated farmland application rate of manure, antibiotics and estrogens may cause high ecological risks to terrestrial organisms according to the risk quotient evaluation. Estrogens could pose a relatively higher risk than antibiotics. The toxicological effects of antibiotics and estrogens to the terrestrial environment should receive more intensive study.
environmental sciences,public, environmental & occupational health
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: the presence of veterinary antibiotics and estrogen - like hormones in animal manure in concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs) and their potential ecological risks. Specifically, the researchers focus on the following aspects: 1. **Ubiquity of antibiotics and estrogen - like hormones**: - The paper investigated the concentrations of 24 antibiotics and 4 estrogen - like hormones in 71 concentrated animal feeding operations in northern China. - The research results show that these micropollutants are ubiquitous in manure. The antibiotic concentration ranges from not detected (ND) to 543,445 μg/kg (average: 44,568 μg/kg), while the estrogen concentration ranges from ND to 249.8 μg/kg (average: 24.78 μg/kg). 2. **Differences in antibiotics and estrogens in different animal manures**: - There are significant differences in the content of antibiotics in different animal manures, in the order of: pigs (83,177 μg/kg)> chickens (52,932 μg/kg)> beef cattle (37,120 μg/kg)> dairy cows (305 μg/kg). - The content of estrogens in dairy cow (average: 39.27 μg/kg) and chicken manure (average: 40.08 μg/kg) is higher than that in beef cattle (2.7 μg/kg) and pig manure (1.8 μg/kg). 3. **Ecological risk assessment**: - Based on the estimated amount of manure application in farmland, antibiotics and estrogens may pose a high ecological risk to terrestrial organisms. - The risk of estrogens is relatively high, and more attention should be paid to their toxicological effects on the environment. 4. **Lack of data and research gaps**: - Compared with antibiotics, the data on the occurrence of estrogens in CAFO manure and their related risks are more limited. Especially under the CAFO model, the occurrence and environmental migration of estrogens are still unclear. Through the above research, the author hopes to fill the knowledge gap in this field and provide a scientific basis for relevant policy - making to reduce the potential threats of these chemicals to the ecosystem and human health.