Laboratory observations for two-dimensional solute transport in an aquifer-aquitard system

Xu Li,Zhang Wen,Hongbin Zhan,Fuxian Wu,Qi Zhu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-021-13123-1
IF: 5.8
2021-03-18
Environmental Science and Pollution Research
Abstract:Low-permeability media such as clay appear in nearly all hydrogeological systems. To date, although significant efforts have been put forward by hydrologists, transport mechanism is still not well understood in such media, especially in an aquifer-aquitard system. In this study, two-dimensional experiments of groundwater flow and solute transport were conducted in a clay-sand two-layer system to investigate the characteristics of flow and transport in such a system. Sodium chloride (NaCl) (a conservative tracer) from a tank was injected after passing by the pre-inlet reservoir where the mixing effect and flow transiency were analyzed. A new numerical model considering the mixing effect and flow transiency was developed to interpret the experimental data based on the finite-element COMSOL Multiphysics platform. Transport parameters were assessed by best fitting the observed breakthrough curves (BTCs). Several important results were obtained. Firstly, aquitard advection was found to be non-negligible and should be considered in a proper mathematical model for describing the transport process. Secondly, advective velocities were temporally variable and showed decreasing trends in the sand and clay layers, mainly due to the impacts of physical and biological clogging. Thirdly, the mixing effect in the pre-inlet reservoir led to a lower tracer concentration in the sand layer at early times. Finally, the observed BTCs exhibited early arrivals in the clay layer, possibly resulting from preferential flow pathways. These findings can provide hints for contamination remediation works in aquifer-aquitard systems.
environmental sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the solute transport mechanism in low - permeability media (such as clay), especially in the aquifer - aquitard system. Specifically, the research aims to explore the influence of the following key factors on solute transport through two - dimensional experiments and numerical simulations: 1. **Convection in the aquitard**: Previous studies often overlooked the convection in the aquitard, but this study shows that this effect cannot be ignored and should be considered in the mathematical model describing the transport process. 2. **Mixing effect in the pre - inlet reservoir**: Many previous mathematical models ignored the mixing effect in the pre - inlet reservoir, which can lead to significant errors in the estimation of transport parameters. This study considered this effect and developed a new numerical model to interpret the experimental data. 3. **Flow transience caused by clogging**: Due to physical, chemical or biological clogging, the flow velocity changes over time, and this transience also affects solute transport. The research observed this phenomenon through experiments and incorporated it into the model. ### Specific problem description - **Convection in the aquitard**: In the aquitard, although its permeability is low, convection still exists and may have an important impact on solute transport. Therefore, an appropriate mathematical model is required to describe this transport process. - **Mixing effect in the pre - inlet reservoir**: When the tracer enters the pre - inlet reservoir, it will mix with the tracer - free water in the reservoir, causing the tracer concentration to gradually increase and finally stabilize. This mixing effect has a significant impact on the evaluation of transport parameters. - **Flow transience caused by clogging**: Due to the clogging effect, the flow velocities in the aquifer and the aquitard decrease over time, which will affect the solute transport behavior. The research observed this phenomenon through experiments and incorporated it into the model. ### Research methods To explore the above problems, the researchers conducted two - dimensional groundwater flow and solute transport experiments. The experimental system included a sand layer and a clay layer. By injecting sodium chloride (NaCl) as a conservative tracer, the researchers measured the conductivity changes at different positions and recorded the solute breakthrough curves (BTCs). Based on these experimental data, a new numerical model was developed. This model considered the mixing effect and flow transience and was simulated using the COMSOL Multiphysics platform. ### Main conclusions 1. The convection in the aquitard cannot be ignored and should be considered in the mathematical model. 2. The convection velocity changes over time, mainly affected by physical and biological clogging. 3. The mixing effect in the pre - inlet reservoir results in a lower tracer concentration in the sand layer in the early time. 4. The observed BTCs show an early arrival phenomenon in the clay layer, which may be due to preferential flow paths. These findings provide valuable references for the pollution remediation work in the aquifer - aquitard system.