Abstract:<h3>Background</h3><p>In high-throughput studies, hundreds to millions of hypotheses are typically tested. Statistical methods that control the false discovery rate (FDR) have emerged as popular and powerful tools for error rate control. While classic FDR methods use only <em>p</em> values as input, more modern FDR methods have been shown to increase power by incorporating complementary information as informative covariates to prioritize, weight, and group hypotheses. However, there is currently no consensus on how the modern methods compare to one another. We investigate the accuracy, applicability, and ease of use of two classic and six modern FDR-controlling methods by performing a systematic benchmark comparison using simulation studies as well as six case studies in computational biology.</p><h3>Results</h3><p>Methods that incorporate informative covariates are modestly more powerful than classic approaches, and do not underperform classic approaches, even when the covariate is completely uninformative. The majority of methods are successful at controlling the FDR, with the exception of two modern methods under certain settings. Furthermore, we find that the improvement of the modern FDR methods over the classic methods increases with the informativeness of the covariate, total number of hypothesis tests, and proportion of truly non-null hypotheses.</p><h3>Conclusions</h3><p>Modern FDR methods that use an informative covariate provide advantages over classic FDR-controlling procedures, with the relative gain dependent on the application and informativeness of available covariates. We present our findings as a practical guide and provide recommendations to aid researchers in their choice of methods to correct for false discoveries.</p>

2 False Discovery Rate

A statistical method for the conservative adjustment of false discovery rate (q-value)

False Discovery Control in Multiple Testing: A Brief Overview of Theories and Methodologies

Online control of the false discovery rate in biomedical research

Controlling the Rate of GWAS False Discoveries

On a generalized false discovery rate

Evaluating FDR and stratified FDR control approaches for high-throughput biological studies

Computing Power and Sample Size for the False Discovery Rate in Multiple Applications

On stepdown control of the false discovery proportion

A practical guide to methods controlling false discoveries in computational biology

Null-free False Discovery Rate Control Using Decoy Permutations

A grouped, selectively weighted false discovery rate procedure

False Variable Selection Rates in Regression

False discovery rate control: Moving beyond the Benjamini–Hochberg method

High-Dimensional False Discovery Rate Control for Dependent Variables

Controlling the False Discovery Rate in Subspace Selection

False Discovery Rate Control for Confounder Selection Using Mirror Statistics

A method to construct refracting profiles

Large-scale Multiple Testing: Fundamental Limits of False Discovery Rate Control and Compound Oracle

Local False Discovery Rate Estimation with Competition-Based Procedures for Variable Selection