Cyclonic wind loads and structural mitigation measures – vulnerability assessment of traditional housings in Odisha

Siddharth Jena,Shuyang Cao,Ajay Gairola
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12040-024-02255-w
2024-03-16
Journal of Earth System Science
Abstract:As global temperatures rise in response to global warming and climate change, the sea-surface temperature of Bay of Bengal shows a rise of 1–2.5oC during the months of May–August. This has led to a change in the pattern of cyclones, occurring specifically in the Bay of Bengal, along with the increased frequency of cyclone occurrences. The cyclones in 2018–2022 have been found to intensify rapidly from a low-pressure disturbance to severe cyclonic storm within 48–54 hours. While meteorological forecasting predicts the onset and wind speed, the holistic wind profile for an intensifying cyclone changes rapidly with time and interference from nearby structures. The damage to life and property depends on the structural integrity of structures. With modernization, the number of concrete masonry structures has increased. The coastal-rural zones of Odisha are known to consist of traditional housing made of different materials like rammed earth, wooden rafters with thatched roofs made of paddy stubble and wooden frames, stone with mud and in few cases, a mix of cement, wood and stones. Although the materials vary, the shape of traditional houses, schools and temples were found to be either gabble roofed or hip-roofed. Studies done in the past highlight the increased vulnerability of gabble-roofed structures to severe destruction levels. Most of the previous research focuses on cyclone forecasting, zonation, and vulnerability analysis based on socio-economic parameters. A thorough structural vulnerability analysis and ranking of traditional housing is a must, considering the fact that the number and intensity of cyclones are rising. And also, the fact that as per the Economic Survey of 2018, 45% of coastal-rural households fall below the poverty line and rely on traditional modes of construction. The authors carried out a thorough on-field post-damage assessment of 2019 cyclone Fani and compared it with the historical data of damage caused to traditional structures due to past cyclones. Based on the time histories, recurrence period and intensity of cyclonic winds, different levels of vulnerability were assigned to the traditional structures of houses, schools and temples. A fragility function was designed to quantify the vulnerability levels. A detailed scientific interpretation of destruction/failure mechanisms is also presented. Further, to quantify the structural behaviour under cyclonic wind load, the cyclonic wind profile was modelled numerically, and validated with wind tunnel testing and finite element analysis was done on various structural members of a traditional gabble roof structure to study the loads and reactions of members. The consequences received showcased novel findings, such as temples being found to be structurally more stable to cyclonic wind loads. Based on the structural analysis and vulnerability levels, economically viable strengthening measures are provided for both, existing traditional structures and structures currently under construction.
geosciences, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?