High HIV diversity, recombination, and superinfection revealed in a large outbreak among persons who inject drugs in Kentucky and Ohio, USA

William M Switzer,Anupama Shankar,Hongwei Jia,Sergey Knyazev,Frank Ambrosio,Reagan Kelly,HaoQiang Zheng,Ellsworth M Campbell,Roxana Cintron,Yi Pan,Neeraja Saduvala,Nivedha Panneer,Rhiannon Richman,Manny B Singh,Douglas A Thoroughman,Erin F Blau,George M Khalil,Sheryl Lyss,Walid Heneine
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/ve/veae015
IF: 5.614
2024-02-19
Virus Evolution
Abstract:Abstract We investigated transmission dynamics of a large HIV outbreak among persons who inject drugs (PWID) in Kentucky and Ohio during 2017–2020 by using detailed phylogenetic, network, recombination, and cluster dating analyses. Using polymerase (pol) sequences from 193 people associated with the investigation, we document high HIV-1 diversity, including subtype B (44.6 per cent); numerous circulating recombinant forms (CRFs) including CRF02_AG (2.5 per cent) and CRF02_AG-like (21.8 per cent); and many unique recombinant forms (URFs) composed of CRFs with major subtypes and sub-subtypes (CRF02_AG/B (24.3 per cent), B/CRF02_AG/B (0.5 per cent), and A6/D/B (6.4 per cent)). Cluster analysis of sequences using a 1.5 per cent genetic distance identified 13 clusters, including a 75-member cluster composed of CRF02_AG-like and CRF02_AG/B, an 18-member CRF02_AG/B cluster, subtype B clusters of sizes ranging from two to 23, and a 9-member A6/D and A6/D/B cluster. Recombination and phylogenetic analyses identified CRF02_AG/B variants with 10 unique breakpoints likely originating from subtype B and CRF02_AG-like viruses in the largest clusters. The addition of contact tracing results from Ohio to the genetic networks identified linkage between persons with subtype B, CRF02_AG, and CRF02_AG/B sequences in the clusters supporting de novo recombinant generation. Superinfection prevalence was 13.3 per cent (8/60) in persons with multiple specimens and included infection with B and CRF02_AG; B and CRF02_AG/B; or B and A6/D/B. In addition to the presence of multiple, distinct molecular clusters associated with this outbreak, cluster dating inferred transmission associated with the largest molecular cluster occurred as early as 2006, with high transmission rates during 2017–2018 in certain other molecular clusters. This outbreak among PWID in Kentucky and Ohio was likely driven by rapid transmission of multiple HIV-1 variants including de novo viral recombinants from circulating viruses within the community. Our findings documenting the high HIV-1 transmission rate and clustering through partner services and molecular clusters emphasize the importance of leveraging multiple different data sources and analyses, including those from disease intervention specialist investigations, to better understand outbreak dynamics and interrupt HIV spread.
virology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to study the transmission dynamics in a large-scale HIV outbreak between Kentucky (KY) and Ohio (OH) in the United States. Specifically, the authors explore the following aspects through detailed molecular analysis methods: 1. **HIV Diversity**: The study found that HIV has a high genetic diversity, including different subtypes, circulating recombinant forms (CRFs), and unique recombinant forms (URFs). 2. **Recombination Phenomenon**: Through recombination and phylogenetic analysis, multiple unique recombination breakpoints were discovered. These recombinant viruses may originate from subtype B and CRF02_AG-like viruses. 3. **Superinfection**: The study examined the superinfection status of individuals sampled multiple times and found that approximately 13.3% of individuals exhibited superinfection. 4. **Transmission Network**: By combining sequence data and contact tracing results, a transmission network was constructed to better understand the transmission dynamics and document the origins of some unique recombinant forms. 5. **Time Inference**: Through time inference of the largest molecular clusters, it was found that the transmission of these clusters could be traced back to as early as 2006, and in some other molecular clusters, high transmission rates appeared between 2017 and 2018. In summary, this paper reveals the complexity of the HIV outbreak in this region through detailed molecular analysis and emphasizes the importance of utilizing multiple data sources and analytical methods to better understand and prevent the spread of HIV.