Abstract:Purpose This paper aims to analytically show that in an over-lapping-generation (OLG) model, low earning cohorts bear unwanted risk and absorb higher economic cost than high earning cohorts do. Design/methodology/approach This paper aims to consider the individual's risk appetite, using a simple utility function, based on consumptions and discount rates in each period. This paper calibrates the model according to teh Israeli pension system as a representative of a small open developed organization for economic cooperation and development country. Israel is considered as unique case study in the pension landscape, as it implements almost pure defined contribution pension scheme with continuous trend of pension market capitalization (Giorno and Jacques, 2016). Hence, this study finds Israel suitable for examining the theoretical mix of pension scheme. That model enables exploring combined solutions for adequate old age benefits, involving the first and the second pension pillars, under fiscal constraints. Findings It comes out that for risk-averse individuals, the optimal degree of funding is negatively correlated to asset returns' volatility and positively correlated to earning decile level. The neglect of risk and individual's current earning level will thus overstate the contribution level and funded percentage from total contributions. Moreover, even in an economy with minimum government intervention, and highly developed private pension fund with high average of rate of return, the authors find it is optimal that the pension system contains a sizeable unfunded pillar. This paper innovates by revealing a socio-economic anomaly in design of mix pension systems in favor of high earning cohorts on the expense of economic loss of low earning cohorts. Practical implications The model presented in this paper could be implemented in countries with mix pension systems, as an alternative to public social transfers or means tested, alleviating poverty and inequality in old age. Additionally, this model could raise the public awareness of the financial sustainability of the unfunded pay-as-you-go pillar to diversify financial risk in pension systems, especially for low earning cohort in society. Social implications One area of research that is particularly relevant in this context concerns the issue of alleviating poverty and income inequality. It is often stressed that the prevention of old age poverty is among the central targets of well-designed pension system (Holzmann and Hinz, 2005). The conceptualization of minimum pension guarantee used in this composition allows to clearly capturing the notion of such a poverty and social targets as an integral part of the pension system rolls. Originality/value This paper innovates by revealing a socio-economic anomaly in design of mix pension systems in favor of high earning cohorts on the expense of economic loss of low earning cohorts. That comes to realize through the level of total contribution rates and funded share that are generally optimal for high earning cohorts but not for low earning cohorts. This paper identifies that the effect of anomaly is most significant in a market characterized with high income-inequality level. This paper finds that imposing intra-generational risk sharing instrument in the form of minimum pension guarantee can re-balance pension design among different earning cohorts. This solution demonstrates balancing effect on the entire economy.

A sustainable, variable lifetime retirement income solution for the Chilean pension system

Optimal retirement income tontines

Care-Dependent Tontines

Modern tontine with bequest: Innovation in pooled annuity products

Chile's private pension system at 35: impact and lessons

The Optimal Size and Progressivity of Old-Age Social Security

Pension inequality and collective pensions funds: the trade-offs of pension redistribution

Effects of COVID‐19 early release of pension funds: The case of Chile

Benefit volatility-targeting strategies in lifetime pension pools

Transforming public pensions: A mixed scheme with a credit granted by the state

Investment performance, regulation and incentives: the case of Chilean pension funds

Effects of Future Pension Benefits on Pre-Retirement Labor Supply: Evidence from Chile

The transition to a multi-pillar pension system: the inherent socio-economic anomaly

Maximising with-profit pensions without guarantees

Addressing Longevity Inequality: How Retirement Age Differentiation Can Be Implemented

'Egalitarian pooling and sharing of longevity risk', a.k.a. 'The many ways to skin a tontine cat'

Egalitarian pooling and sharing of longevity risk a.k.a. Can an administrator help skin the tontine cat?

Optimal performance of a tontine overlay subject to withdrawal constraints

Optimal post-retirement investment under longevity risk in collective funds

Hedging longevity risk in defined contribution pension schemes

PRODUCT CHOICE UNDER GOVERNMENT REGULATION: THE CASE OF CHILE'S PRIVATIZED PENSION SYSTEM