Abstract:Carbonaceous particles, such as soot, make up a notable fraction of atmospheric particulate matter and contribute substantially to anthropogenic climate forcing, air pollution, and human health. Thermal-optical analysis (TOA) is one of the most widespread methods used to speciate carbonaceous particles and divides total carbon (TC) into the operationally defined quantities of organic carbon (OC; carbon evolved during slow heating in an inert atmosphere) and elemental carbon (EC). While multiple studies have identified fundamental scientific reasons for uncertainty in distinguishing OC and EC, far fewer studies have reported on interlaboratory reproducibility. Moreover, existing reproducibility studies have focused on complex atmospheric samples. The real-time instruments used for regulatory measurements of aircraft engine non-volatile particulate matter (nvPM) mass emissions are required to be calibrated to the mass of EC determined by TOA of the filter-sampled emissions of a diffusion flame source. However, significant differences have been observed in the calibration factor for the same instrument based on EC content determined by different calibration laboratories. Here, we report on the reproducibility of TC, EC, and OC quantified using the same TOA protocol, instrument model (Sunset 5L), and software settings (auto split-point: Calc405) across five different laboratories and instrument operators. Six unique data sets were obtained, with one laboratory operating two instruments. Samples were collected downstream of an aircraft engine after treatment with a catalytic stripper to remove volatiles. We compared laboratory-reported uncertainties with actual variability in the data set, the difference of which (dark uncertainty) was substantial. Interlaboratory (dark) contributions increase uncertainties by a factor of 1.2 – 1.6 relative to the laboratory-reported uncertainties, even for these relatively simple samples (combustion particles downstream of a stripper), resulting in uncertainties of 26 % ( k = 2) for EC. Uncertainties were a little larger for EC than for OC. These results indicate that current TOA uncertainties are underestimated and should be adjusted upwards to reflect these interlaboratory differences.

Uncertainties in charring correction in the analysis of elemental and organic carbon in atmospheric particles by thermal/optical methods

Intercomparison of thermal-optical methods for the determination of organic and elemental carbon: influences of aerosol composition and implications.

Improved Measurement of Carbonaceous Aerosol: Evaluation of the Sampling Artifacts and Inter-Comparison of the Thermal-Optical Analysis Methods

Evaluation of the thermal/optical reflectance method for discrimination between char- and soot-EC.

Optical Calibration and Equivalence of a Multiwavelength Thermal/Optical Carbon Analyzer

Quality Assurance and Quality Control for Thermal/optical Analysis of Aerosol Samples for Organic and Elemental Carbon

Ambient Organic Carbon to Elemental Carbon Ratios: Influence of the Thermal–optical Temperature Protocol and Implications

Ambient organic carbon to elemental carbon ratios: Influences of the measurement methods and implications

Carbonaceous Aerosols in Megacity Xi'an, China: Implications of Thermal/optical Protocols Comparison

Uncertainties in Thermal-Optical Measurements of Black Carbon: Insights from Source and Ambient Samples.

Quantifying the uncertainties in thermal-optical analysis of carbonaceous aircraft engine emissions: An interlaboratory study

Modeling Reflectance and Transmittance of Quartz-Fiber Filter Samples Containing Elemental Carbon Particles: Implications for Thermal/optical Analysis

Measurement of Carbonaceous Aerosol with Different Sampling Configurations and Frequencies

Evaluation of the thermal/optical reflectance method for quantification of elemental carbon in sediments.

Refining Temperature Measures in Thermal/Optical Carbon Analysis

A Review on the Uncertainty in Carbonecous Aerosol Observation and Investigation

Comparison of Two Thermal-Optical Methods for the Determination of Organic Carbon and Elemental Carbon: Results from the Southeastern United States

An automated method for thermal-optical separation of aerosol organic/elemental carbon for 13C analysis at the sub-μgC level: A comprehensive assessment

Existence and Formation Pathways of High- and Low-Maturity Elemental Carbon from Solid Fuel Combustion by a Time-Resolved Study

The Effects of Accumulated Refractory Particles and the Peak Inert Mode Temperature on Semi-Continuous Organic Carbon and Elemental Carbon Measurements During the CAREBeijing 2006 Campaign

Comparison of Carbon Species Measurement Results in Atmospheric Particulate Matter: Elemental Analysis and TOR Methods