Abstract:The present work examines and compares the approaches of Jacob Bernoulli and Leonhard Euler to the problem of ship propulsion generated by internal forces. Jacob Bernoulli's analysis, developed in the late 17th century, relies on geometric interpretations and algebraic relationships to estimate the impulse exerted by a pendulum within a ship. His results, however, are shown to overestimate the force by scaling it with the height of fall rather than the velocity at the end of the fall and by amplifying it with a time dependence factor that proves to be erroneous. Euler's subsequent analysis, conducted nearly 50 years later, provides a more rigorous and mechanically sound treatment of the problem. Utilizing differential equations and a deeper understanding of the principles of motion, Euler demonstrates that no net motion can be generated by internal forces alone, thus refuting the concept of perpetual motion as proposed by Jacob Bernoulli. By comparing the two methodologies, this work highlights the evolution of mathematical and physical analysis from the intuitive but flawed approaches of the early calculus pioneers to the more precise and reliable methods established by later mathematicians. Euler's work not only corrects the errors in Jacob Bernoulli's analysis but also solidifies the understanding that propulsion requires external forces, a conclusion consistent with the laws of Newtonian mechanics.

An annotated translation from Latin of L. Euler's 'On the motion of boats propelled by oars in rivers'

A translation of L. Euler's " Examination of an artifice for propelling a ship by the principle of internal motion"

Translation of Leonhard Euler's: General Principles of the Motion of Fluids

A translation of L. Euler's "Considerations on the motion of celestial bodies"

Early theories on fluid resistance and translation of Euler's "Dilucidationes de resistentia fluidorum"

Evaluating Jacob Bernoulli's Ship Propulsion Artifice: Euler's Analysis and Critique

German to Spanish translation of Einstein's work on the formation of meanders in rivers

A translation of L. Euler's "On the motion of comets in parabolic orbits, having the Sun in the focus"

On the Fundamental Function in the Theory of Steady Motion of Ships

Euler and the Ordinary Differential Equations

Principles of the motion of fluids

THE FUNDAMENTAL SOLUTION IN THE THEORY OF STEADY MOTION OF A SHIP

Methodus inveniendi lineas curvas maximi minimive proprietate gaudentes, sive solutio problematis isoperimetrici lattissimo sensu accepti

An English translation of L. Euler's "Calculations on aerostatic balloons made by the late Mr. Leonhard Euler, as they were found on his blackboard, after his death on 7 September 1783"

Translating scientific Latin texts with artificial intelligence: the works of Euler and contemporaries

Attempt at a theory of the friction of fluids

POTENTIAL THEORY OF STEADY MOTION OF SHIPS. PARTS 1 AND 2

On divergent Series

A Perturbation Analysis of the Wavemaking of a Ship, with an Interpretation of Guilloton’s Method

Appendix to Lecture I: Bifurcations, semiflows, and navier-stokes equations

Newton vs. Euler–Lagrange approach, or how and when beam equations are variational