Abstract:Background: Opinion leadership, educational outreach visiting, and innovation championing are commonly used strategies to address barriers to implementing innovations and evidence-based practices in healthcare settings. Despite voluminous research, ambiguities persist in how these strategies work and under what conditions they work well, work poorly, or work at all. The current paper develops middle-range theories to address this gap. Methods: Conceptual articles, systematic reviews, and empirical studies informed the development of causal pathway diagrams (CPDs). CPDs are visualization tools for depicting and theorizing about the causal process through which strategies operate, including the mechanisms they activate, the barriers they address, and the proximal and distal outcomes they produce. CPDs also clarify the contextual conditions (i.e., preconditions and moderators) that influence whether, and to what extent, the strategy's causal process unfolds successfully. Expert panels of implementation scientists and health professionals rated the plausibility of these preliminary CPDs and offered comments and suggestions on them. Findings: Theoretically, opinion leadership addresses potential adopters' uncertainty about likely consequences of innovation use (determinant) by promoting positive attitude formation about the innovation (mechanism), which results in an adoption decision (proximal outcome), which leads to innovation use (intermediate outcome). As this causal process repeats, penetration, or spread of innovation use, occurs (distal outcome). Educational outreach visiting addresses knowledge barriers, attitudinal barriers, and behavioral barriers (determinants) by promoting critical thinking and reflection about evidence and practice (mechanism), which results in behavioral intention (proximal outcome), behavior change (intermediate outcome), and fidelity, or guideline adherence (distal outcome). Innovation championing addresses organizational inertia, indifference, and resistance (determinants) by promoting buy-in to the vision, fostering a positive implementation climate, and increasing collective efficacy (mechanisms), which leads to participation in implementation activities (proximal outcome), initial use of the innovation with increasing skill (intermediate outcome) and, ultimately, greater penetration and fidelity (distal outcomes). Experts found the preliminary CPDs plausible or highly plausible and suggested additional mechanisms, moderators, and preconditions, which were used to amend the initial CPD. Discussion: The middle-range theories depicted in the CPDs furnish testable propositions for implementation research and offer guidance for selecting, designing, and evaluating these social influence implementation strategies in both research studies and practice settings.

Strategies of Network Intervention: A Pragmatic Approach to Policy Implementation and Public Problem Resolution through Network Science

Network Interventions: Applying Network Science for Pragmatic Action in Public Administration and Policy

Developing a typology of network alteration strategies for implementation: a scoping review and iterative synthesis

Network Inference in Public Administration: Questions, Challenges, and Models of Causality

Managing Complex Networks: Strategies for the Public Sector

Three Traditions of Network Research: What the Public Management Research Agenda Can Learn from Other Research Communities

Structural Interventions in Networks

Undermining and Strengthening Social Networks through Network Modification

Networks and Public Administration

Networks, Management and Institutions: Public Administration as 'Normal Science'

Formalizing psychological interventions through network control theory

The Evolution of Social Network Analysis in Public Administration

Social network analysis and public policy: what’s new?

Advancing Evidence-Based Public Health Policy: How Core Component Thinking Can Illuminate the Multilevel Nature of Public Health Policy

Complex Interventions for a Complex System? Using Systems Thinking to Explore Ways to Address Unhealthy Commodity Industry Influence on Public Health Policy

Working Toward Network Governance: Local Actors’ Strategies for Navigating Tensions in Localized Health Care Governance

Moving policy implementation theory forward: A multiple streams/critical juncture approach

Practical Challenges of Systems Thinking and Modeling in Public Health

Public Intervention Strategies for Distressed Communities

Network Governance in Action: Functions and Practices to Foster Collaborative Environments

Changing hearts and minds: theorizing how, when, and under what conditions three social influence implementation strategies work