Abstract:The new energy vehicle industry has gained a considerable amount of attention in recent years. However, the high cost of battery R&D reduces the competitiveness of battery electric vehicle (BEV) products. In this context, government might choose to support BEV companies in product innovation. In this paper, we examine the performance of government R&D subsidy by considering supply chain downstream competition. To capture the impacts of downstream competition, we model a two-tier supply chain consisting of a high-end encroachment manufacturer and an incumbent manufacturer who source from a same battery supplier. Result shows that downstream competition might reduce upstream battery R&D. In addition, when the consumer preference for the high-end substitutable BEV is less than a threshold, the BEV market scale will diminish due to competition. Furthermore, downstream competition might hurt the supplier’s profitability. For the impacts of R&D subsidy, result suggests that it performs better under competition on increasing supplier R&D activity. Regarding supply chain stakeholders, R&D subsidy always increases supply chain members’ profits and consumer surplus without competition. While, under downstream competition, it only increases supplier profit, but does not always benefits manufacturers and consumer surplus. Specifically, we identify the Pareto regions in which R&D subsidy increases both profits and consumer surplus. We extend the models by considering supplier non-uniform pricing and monopoly by the high-end BEV manufacturer. The above analyses are robust in the extended models and new findings are derived. Our findings are instructive for both BEV supply chain stakeholders and policy makers.

Product R&D Strategy of New Energy Vehicle Enterprises Embedded with Technical Services Under the Subsidy Threshold

Study of the retreating product subsidy policy based on technology thresholds of new energy vehicle consumers

R&D investment in new energy vehicles with purchase subsidy based on technology adoption life cycle and customers’ choice behaviour

R&D Investment Strategies for New Energy Vehicles Firm Based on Consumers’ Preference and Government Subsidy

Research on the development strategy selection of the new energy vehicle industry from the perspective of green credit—Based on the foursquare evolutionary game analysis

Advancing to Full Electrification of Rideshare Vehicles: Applying Differentiated Subsidy Phase-out Policies to Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicles and Battery Electric Vehicles Through an Evolutionary Game Analysis

Sustainability of the New Energy Automobile Industry: Examining the Relationship among Government Subsidies, R&D Intensity, and Innovation Performance

Impact of financial subsidies on the R&D intensity of new energy vehicles: A case study of 88 listed enterprises in China

Differential Game Research on the Development of New Energy Automobile Enterprises under the Background of Subsidy Retreat

Policy analysis on the promotion of new energy vehicles in China considering consumers' car purchasing choices in the "post-subsidy era": based on the study of a three-party evolutionary game

The effective subsidy policies for new energy vehicles considering both supply and demand sides and their influence mechanisms: An analytical perspective from the network-based evolutionary game

Game-Theoretic Analysis of Price and Quantity Decisions for Electric Vehicle Supply Chain Under Subsidy Reduction

Is government R&D subsidy good for BEV supply chain? The challenge from downstream competition

The Impact of Purchase Subsidy on Enterprises’ R&D Efforts: Evidence from China’s New Energy Vehicle Industry

The Effectiveness of Government Subsidies on Manufacturing Innovation: Evidence from the New Energy Vehicle Industry in China

Analysis of the impact of financial subsidies on R&D investment of new energy vehicle enterprises based on threshold regression

Dual-Credit Policy of new energy automobile at China: Inhibiting scale or intermediary of innovation?

Impact of government subsidy on the optimal R&D and advertising investment in the cooperative supply chain of new energy vehicles

The Effects of Subsidy Policy on Electric Vehicles and the Supporting Regulatory Policies: Evidence From Micro Data of Chinese Mobile Manufacturers

Cooperation and Production Strategy of Power Battery for New Energy Vehicles Under Carbon Cap-And-Trade Policy

Research on “Subsidy Defraud” of New Energy Vehicles Enterprises Based on Signal Game