A framework for measuring weak values without weak interactions and its diagrammatic representation
Kazuhisa Ogawa,Osamu Yasuhiko,Hirokazu Kobayashi,Toshihiro Nakanishi,Akihisa Tomita
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/ab0773
2019-04-10
New Journal of Physics
Abstract:Weak values are typically obtained experimentally by performing weak measurements, which involve weak interactions between the measured system and a probe. However, the determination of weak values does not necessarily require weak measurements, and several methods without weak system-probe interactions have been developed previously. In this work, a framework for measuring weak values is proposed to describe the relationship between various weak value measurement techniques in a unified manner. This framework, which uses a probe-controlled system transformation instead of the weak system-probe interaction, improves the understanding of the currently used weak value measurement methods. Furthermore, a diagrammatic representation of the proposed framework is introduced to intuitively identify the complex values obtained in each measurement system. By using this diagram, a new method for measuring weak values with a desired function can be systematically derived. As an example, a scan-free and more efficient direct measurement method of wavefunctions than the conventional techniques using weak measurements is developed.The concept of weak values was first introduced by Aharonov <em>et al</em> [<a href="#njpab0773bib1">1</a>] as observable statistics influenced not only by the initial state , but also by the final state of the studied system. The weak value of the observable is defined as , which is generally a complex number. Weak values are typically determined experimentally using a technique called weak measurements. In weak measurements, a probe interacts with the system weakly enough not to significantly disturb the system. After the post-selection of the system's final state, a weak value is obtained as the average of the measurement outcomes of the probe. Weak values have been used to study various fundamental problems in quantum mechanics [<a href="#njpab0773bib2">2</a>–<a href="#njpab0773bib10">10</a>] because they represent intermediate aspects of pre- and post-selected systems. In addition, weak values are used for the precise measurement of the magnitudes of weak system-probe interactions [<a href="#njpab0773bib11">11</a>–<a href="#njpab0773bib15">15</a>] because they can exceed the eigenvalues of the observables. Furthermore, weak values are utilized for the direct measurement of complex functions such as wavefunctions and pseudo-probability distributions of the initial state of the system [<a href="#njpab0773bib16">16</a>–<a href="#njpab0773bib25">25</a>].In these previous studies, weak values have been obtained by weak measurements, which involve weak system-probe interactions. However, this is not the only possible method for their determination, and several alternative weak value measurement techniques that do not involve weak system-probe interactions have been recently developed, including those using strong system-probe interactions [<a href="#njpab0773bib26">26</a>–<a href="#njpab0773bib29">29</a>], modular values [<a href="#njpab0773bib30">30</a>], quantum control interactions [<a href="#njpab0773bib31">31</a>, <a href="#njpab0773bib32">32</a>], an enlarged Hilbert space [<a href="#njpab0773bib33">33</a>], coupling-deformed pointer observables [<a href="#njpab0773bib34">34</a>], and a combination of several strong measurements of the system [<a href="#njpab0773bib35">35</a>]. It should be noted here that most of them [<a href="#njpab0773bib26">26</a>–<a href="#njpab0773bib33">33</a>] and some weak measurement experiments [<a href="#njpab0773bib2">2</a>–<a href="#njpab0773bib10">10</a>, <a href="#njpab0773bib16">16</a>–<a href="#njpab0773bib24">24</a>] use qubit systems as the probes. They all have the same measurement procedure of the qubit probes to obtain complex weak values—measuring expectation values of two operators, such as Pauli-X and Pauli-Y. Therefore, it is expected that these weak value measurement methods using qubit probes can be understood in a unified framework.In this work, we propose a framework for measuring weak values common to the conventional weak measurement using a qubit probe and other weak value measurement techniques. This framework uses a probe-controlled system transformation instead of the weak system-probe interaction to obtain a unified description of the relationship between these measurement methods. In addition, a diagrammatic representation of the proposed framework is introduced. It illustrates the time evolution of the system's state for each probe mode and allows us to intuitively identify the complex values obtained in each measurement system. Furthermore, using the transformation rule of the diagram, a new weak value measurement method that has a desired function, such as measurement precision and a simple experimental setup, can be systematically derived, regardless of the type of physical systems. As an example, this transformation rule is applied to a direct measurement method of wavefunct <p>-Abstract Truncated-</p>
physics, multidisciplinary