Abstract:The selection of a data processing method for use in mass spectrometry-based label-free proteome quantification contributes significantly to its accuracy and precision. In this study, we comprehensively evaluated 7 commonly-used label-free quantification methods (MaxQuant-Spectrum count, MaxQuant-iBAQ, MaxQuant-LFQ, MaxQuant-LFAQ, Proteome Discoverer, MetaMorpheus, TPP-StPeter) with a focus on missing values, precision, accuracy, selectivity, and reproducibility of low abundance protein quantification in both single shot and fractionation. Our results showed that among the tested strategies, MaxQuant in MaxLFQ mode outperformed other strategies in terms of accuracy and precision in both whole proteome and low abundance proteome quantification, whereas the Proteome Discoverer (PD) strategy using SEQUEST as a search engine performed better in terms of quantifiable low abundance proteome coverage. We subsequently applied the PD and MaxLFQ strategies in a blood proteomic dataset and found that many FDA-approved tumor prognostic biomarkers could be identified as well as quantified using the PD strategy, indicating the potential advantage of PD in label-free quantification studies. These results provide a reference for method choice in label-free quantification data analysis. SIGNIFICANCE: Mass spectrometry-based label-free quantification methods play an important role in label-free proteome data analysis. In this study, we evaluated 7 commonly-used label-free quantification methods with respect to the following aspects: missing values, precision, accuracy, selectivity, and reproducibility for low abundance protein quantification. The results showed that, among the strategies evaluated, the PD strategy with SEQUEST as a search engine performed better in terms of low abundance protein coverage. This study provides a reference for method choice in label-free quantification data analysis.

Quantification of absolute labeling efficiency at the single-protein level

Comparative evaluation of label-free quantification strategies.

Label-Free Quantification of Molecular Interaction in Live Red Blood Cells by Tracking Nanometer Scale Membrane Fluctuations.

Quantitation and localization of protein molecules in living cells

Label-Free Imaging of Single Proteins and Binding Kinetics Using Total Internal Reflection-Based Evanescent Scattering Microscopy

An Accurate Proteomic Quantification Method: Fluorescence Labeling Absolute Quantification (FLAQ) Using Multidimensional Liquid Chromatography and Tandem Mass Spectrometry.

Superresolution Imaging with Single-Antibody Labeling

Detection and quantification of C-terminally tagged proteins by in-gel fluorescence

Peptide Biosynthesis with Stable Isotope Labeling from a Cell-free Expression System for Targeted Proteomics with Absolute Quantification

Quantification of Binding of Small Molecules to Native Proteins Overexpressed in Living Cells

Quantitative single-protein imaging reveals molecular complex formation of integrin, talin, and kindlin during cell adhesion

Amino Acid Residue Specific Stable Isotope Labeling for Quantitative Proteomics

ProDOL: a general method to determine the degree of labeling for staining optimization and molecular counting

Site-specific protein labeling strategies for super-resolution microscopy

New Set of Isobaric Labeling Reagents for Quantitative 16Plex Proteomics

Label-Free Quantification of Small-Molecule Binding to Membrane Proteins on Single Cells by Tracking Nanometer-Scale Cellular Membrane Deformation.

Absolute quantum yield measurements of fluorescent proteins using a plasmonic nanocavity

Single molecule identification and quantification of whole proteins without purification, proteolysis, or labeling: a computational model

Quantitative Imaging of Proteins in Tissue by Stable Isotope Labeled Mimetic Liquid Extraction Surface Analysis Mass Spectrometry

Analysis of the Protein Complex Associated with 14-3-3 Epsilon by a Deuterated-Leucine Labeling Quantitative Proteomics Strategy

Suborgan Level Quantitation of Proteins in Tissues Delivered by Polymeric Nanocarriers