Abstract:Several computer programs are available for detecting copy number variants (CNVs) using genome-wide SNP arrays. We evaluated the performance of four CNV detection software suites-Birdsuite, Partek, HelixTree, and PennCNV-Affy-in the identification of both rare and common CNVs. Each program's performance was assessed in two ways. The first was its recovery rate, i.e., its ability to call 893 CNVs previously identified in eight HapMap samples by paired-end sequencing of whole-genome fosmid clones, and 51,440 CNVs identified by array Comparative Genome Hybridization (aCGH) followed by validation procedures, in 90 HapMap CEU samples. The second evaluation was program performance calling rare and common CNVs in the Bipolar Genome Study (BiGS) data set (1001 bipolar cases and 1033 controls, all of European ancestry) as measured by the Affymetrix SNP 6.0 array. Accuracy in calling rare CNVs was assessed by positive predictive value, based on the proportion of rare CNVs validated by quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR), while accuracy in calling common CNVs was assessed by false positive/false negative rates based on qPCR validation results from a subset of common CNVs. Birdsuite recovered the highest percentages of known HapMap CNVs containing >20 markers in two reference CNV datasets. The recovery rate increased with decreased CNV frequency. In the tested rare CNV data, Birdsuite and Partek had higher positive predictive values than the other software suites. In a test of three common CNVs in the BiGS dataset, Birdsuite's call was 98.8% consistent with qPCR quantification in one CNV region, but the other two regions showed an unacceptable degree of accuracy. We found relatively poor consistency between the two "gold standards,'' the sequence data of Kidd et al., and aCGH data of Conrad et al. Algorithms for calling CNVs especially common ones need substantial improvement, and a "gold standard'' for detection of CNVs remains to be established.

CNVbd: A Method for Copy Number Variation Detection and Boundary Search

Accuracy Of Cnv Detection From Gwas Data

DL-CNV: A Deep Learning Method for Identifying Copy Number Variations Based on Next Generation Target Sequencing

CNV-TV: A Robust Method to Discover Copy Number Variation from Short Sequencing Reads

SeqCNV: a Novel Method for Identification of Copy Number Variations in Targeted Next-Generation Sequencing Data

A Cluster-Based Approach for the Discovery of Copy Number Variations from Next-Generation Sequencing Data

RKDOSCNV: A Local Kernel Density-Based Approach to the Detection of Copy Number Variations by Using Next-Generation Sequencing Data

CNV-P: a machine-learning framework for predicting high confident copy number variations

nbCNV: a multi-constrained optimization model for discovering copy number variants in single-cell sequencing data

Comparative Studies of Copy Number Variation Detection Methods for Next-Generation Sequencing Technologies

Copy Number Variation Detection In Whole-Genome Sequencing Data Using The Bayesian Information Criterion

Combinatorial Detection Algorithm for Copy Number Variations Using High-throughput Sequencing Reads

CRSCNV: A Cross-Model-Based Statistical Approach to Detect Copy Number Variations in Sequence Data

Copy number variation estimation from multiple next-generation sequencing samples.

IhybCNV: an Intra-Hybrid Approach for CNV Detection from Next-Generation Sequencing Data

PEcnv: accurate and efficient detection of copy number variations of various lengths

DeepCNV: a deep learning approach for authenticating copy number variations

Copy Number Variation Detection Based on Constraint Least Squares

A Single Cell Level Based Method For Copy Number Variation Analysis By Low Coverage Massively Parallel Sequencing

Detection of Common Copy Number Variation with Application to Population Clustering from Next Generation Sequencing Data.

Copy Number Variation Detection Using Total Variation