Abstract:Recently, the paper by Wu et al. (2014), “Estimation and Uncertainty Analysis of Impacts of Future Heat Waves on Mortality in the Eastern United States,” concluded that “the major sources of uncertainty were the relative risk estimates for mortality on heat wave versus non–heat wave days, the RCP scenarios, and the heat wave definitions.” One conclusion to be drawn from reading this manuscript might be that a good definition of “heat wave” based on epidemiological studies and accurate determination of the risks associated with such temperatures would greatly reduce these uncertainties. Although the authors allude to the possible geographic variability of these risks, there is nevertheless no mention of the possible evolution over time that can take place both in heat-wave definition temperatures and in the modifications of these possible impacts, beyond those stemming from the use of air-conditioning equipment and the implementation of heat-wave prevention plans. Along these lines, recent studies have found that demographic and socioeconomic factors may be behind the trend in minimum mortality temperatures (Miron et al. 2008). Hence, in Castile-La Mancha (Spain) the minimum mortality temperature went from 32°C in the decade 1975–1985 to 28°C in 1995–2003 as a consequence of population aging. This fact influences the heat-wave definition temperatures, which are very closely linked to the age group > 65 years (Montero et al. 2012). Added to this uncertainty are the shifts over time observed in the impact of heat waves. Studies conducted in different parts of the world show that, far from remaining constant, these impacts are changing over time, with a trend toward minimizing such effects (Schifano et al. 2012): Although the effect is most pronounced in cardiovascular mortality (Ha and Kim 2013), it has remained practically constant in the case of respiratory mortality (Miron et al, in press). These results, obtained from a time series covering > 30 years, show that the increase in risk of heat-related mortality for each degree centigrade that the threshold temperature is exceeded went from 13.7% in 1975–1985 to 7.4% in 1997–2008, and specifically that this decline was attributable to circulatory causes, going from 18.2% in 1975–1985 to 5.8% in 1997–2008. In the case of respiratory causes, however, no such decline was in evidence, with the respective figures remaining practically constant: 11.8% in 1975–1985 versus 13.5% in 1997–2008. This pattern would seem to be linked to improvements in health care services (particularly in the case of patients with cardiovascular diseases), socioeconomic improvements, and the provision of infrastructures for better living conditions. It therefore follows that any changes in the trend of these parameters could reverse the situation and increase the effects of temperature extremes on mortality. This decline in heat wave–related mortality does not appear to be connected with the implementation of prevention plans, in Spain at least (Culqui et al. 2013). Because the factors that appear to influence the shifts in the relationship between temperature and mortality are not local and are thus extrapolatable to a large proportion of developed countries, their relevance is self-evident. These uncertainties add to those already cited in the paper by Wu et al. and highlight the need for more in-depth knowledge, not only of temperature forecasts at the different time horizons, but also of the behavior pattern over time of the temperature–mortality relationship. Far from being constant, this relationship displays a time trend that is seldom taken into account in the models used to predict the impact of climate change on human health.

A data-driven framework for the definition of heat in CV research for better comprehension of climate changes on human health

A Method to Identify Individually Physiological Response Differences to Heat Exposure Using Comprehensive Deviation Coefficient (CDC)

Spatially Explicit Mapping of Heat Health Risk Utilizing Environmental and Socioeconomic Data

Evaluating the Sensitivity of Heat Wave Definitions among North Carolina Physiographic Regions

Defining indoor heat thresholds for health in the UK

A New Method to Estimate Heat Exposure Days and Its Impacts in China

Methodological Approaches for Measuring the Association Between Heat Exposure and Health Outcomes: A Comprehensive Global Scoping Review

On adjustment for temperature in heatwave epidemiology: a new method and toward clarification of methods to estimate health effects of heatwaves

Multiple Trigger Points for Quantifying Heat-Health Impacts: New Evidence from a Hot Climate

Comparing Approximated Heat Stress Measures Across the United States

Web-Based Data to Quantify Meteorological and Geographical Effects on Heat Stroke: Case Study in China

Performance of Heat-Health Warning Systems in Shanghai Evaluated by Using Local Heat-Related Illness Data

Systematic identification of heat events associated with emergency admissions to enhance the heat-health action plan in a subtropical city: a data-driven approach

Machine learning approaches to identify thresholds in a heat-health warning system context

Impact of Heat Wave Definitions on the Added Effect of Heat Waves on Cardiovascular Mortality in Beijing, China

Regional variation in the role of humidity on city-level heat-related mortality

Heat and cause-specific cardiopulmonary mortality in Germany: a case-crossover study using small-area assessment

The Time Trend Temperature–Mortality As a Factor of Uncertainty Analysis of Impacts of Future Heat Waves

Disparities in the impact of heat wave definitions on emergency department visits during the first year of life among preterm and full-term infants in California

Short-term Effects of Heatwaves on Clinical and Subclinical Cardiovascular Indicators in Chinese Adults: A Distributed Lag Analysis

Defining region-specific heatwave in China based on a novel concept of “avoidable mortality for each temperature unit decrease”