What will robots think of us?

Robin R. Murphy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/scirobotics.adn6096

IF: 25

2024-02-02

Science Robotics

Abstract:Two recent science fiction novels humorously illustrate the importance of correct robot mental models.

robotics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Would robots really bother with a bloody uprising?

Robin R Murphy,Robin R. Murphy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/scirobotics.adr2950

IF: 25

2024-08-02

Science Robotics

Abstract:In the amusing 1982 novel Software , robots punish their human overlords by raising prices on longevity drugs and organ transplants.

robotics
Robot Be Good

Michael Anderson,Susan Leigh Anderson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/scientificamerican1010-72

2010-10-01

Scientific American

Abstract:Autonomous machines will soon play a big role in our lives. It's time they learned how to behave ethically

multidisciplinary sciences
Reflecting on the Presence of Science Fiction Robots in Computing Literature

Omar Mubin,Kewal Wadibhasme,Philipp Jordan,Mohammad Obaid

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3303706

2019-03-22

Abstract:Depictions of robots and AIs in popular science fiction movies and shows have the potential to showcase visions of Human-Robot Interaction (HRI) to the general public and computer science researchers alike. In contrast, studies on the referral, usage, and appropriation of these portrayals by computer scientists in their research publications is an academic void at present. However, such investigations are critical to better understand the potential utility and latent shortcomings of science fiction robots for future HRI research, innovation, and education. To address this research gap, this study investigates the overall presence, nature, and frequency of referrals of 18 popular science fiction robots in the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) Digital Library. These robots were either portrayed in various movies and subsequently inducted into the Robot Hall of Fame, created by Carnegie Mellon University in 2003, or were top-ranked in a user-curated Internet Movie Database (IMDB) list. To do so, we performed full-text search and retrieval queries of all 18 robots in the ACM Digital Library. In total, we identified 121 relevant mentions, across 102 individual publications, in a time span from 1973 to 2017. These 121 mentions were then qualitatively analysed to determine the nature of the robot mentions. Our results indicate that the robot attributes of voice or dialogue were emerging as a popularly mentioned element. In addition, we find that research papers of philosophical nature mention sci-fi robots more frequently than papers of technical or theoretical nature. We also observe that the dystopian element of science fiction is under-utilised, with the majority of robot mentions exhibiting neutral or utopian characteristics. In conclusion, we speculate on our results and present possible avenues of future HRI research on the topic.
Early science fiction got microbots surprisingly right

Robin R Murphy,Robin R. Murphy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/scirobotics.ado1489

IF: 25

2024-02-23

Science Robotics

Abstract:Since 1931, science fiction has speculated on how microbots might work and how they will change our lives.

robotics
Robotics and Artificial Intelligence [From the Editor's Desk]

Bram Vanderborght

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/mra.2020.2984469

2020-06-01

Abstract:One hundred years ago, the Czech writer Karel apek gave us the word robot, which first appeared in his play R.U.R. in 1920 (although, later, he identified his brother Josef as the actual source of the term). Long before science fiction became recognized as a separate genre, apek wrote plays and novels in which he discussed ethical aspects of industrial inventions and processes, including mass production and robots. His robots were not exactly robots as we think of them today; they were living flesh-and-blood creatures rather than assemblages of mechanical components and electronics. Last year, I was invited for a debate following a performance of the famous play. A century after its creation, the theme of robots, in whatever form, is more topical than ever. While man increasingly plays God, his creation threatens to take over more and more. R.U.R. is as visionary as it is relevant, as tragic as it is comical, and as unlikely as it is frightening.

robotics,automation & control systems
Why robots should be technical: Correcting mental models through technical architecture concepts

Lukas Hindemith,Anna-Lisa Vollmer,Jan Phillip Göpfert,Christiane B. Wiebel-Herboth,Britta Wrede

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2011.02731

2020-11-05

Abstract:Research in social robotics is commonly focused on designing robots that imitate human behavior. While this might increase a user's satisfaction and acceptance of robots at first glance, it does not automatically aid a non-expert user in naturally interacting with robots, and might actually hurt their ability to correctly anticipate a robot's capabilities. We argue that a faulty mental model, that the user has of the robot, is one of the main sources of confusion. In this work we investigate how communicating technical concepts of robotic systems to users affects their mental models, and how this can increase the quality of human-robot interaction. We conducted an online study and investigated possible ways of improving users' mental models. Our results underline that communicating technical concepts can form an improved mental model. Consequently, we show the importance of consciously designing robots that express their capabilities and limitations.

Robotics,Human-Computer Interaction
A fictional history of robotics features forgotten real-world robots

Robin R Murphy,Robin R. Murphy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/scirobotics.ado7982

IF: 25

2024-03-28

Science Robotics

Abstract:The science-fiction movie The Creator uses six real-world robots from the 1950s and 1960s to show progress in AI.

robotics
A Short History of the Perception of Robots and Automata from Antiquity to Modern Times

Christian Fron,Oliver Korn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-17107-0_1

2019-01-01

Abstract:Robots and Automata are key elements of every vision and forecast of life in the near and distant future. However, robots and automata also have a long history, which reaches back into Antiquity. Today most historians think that one of the key roles of robots and Automata was to amaze or even terrify the audience: They were designed to express something mythical, magical, and not explainable. Moreover, the visions of robots and their envisioned fields of application reflect the different societies. Therefore, this short history of robotics and (especially) anthropomorphic Automata aims to give an overview of several historical periods and their perspective on the topic. In a second step, this work aims to encourage readers to reflect on the recent discussion about fields of application as well as the role of robotics today and in the future.

computer science, theory & methods, cybernetics
Could robots be regarded as humans in future?

Huansheng Ning,Feifei Shi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2012.05054

2020-12-01

Abstract:With the overwhelming advances in Artificial Intelligence (AI), brain science and neuroscience, robots are developing towards a direction of much more human-like and human-friendly. We can't help but wonder whether robots could be regarded as humans in future? In this article, we propose a novel perspective to analyze the essential difference between humans and robots, that is based on their respective living spaces, particularly the independent and intrinsic thinking space. We finally come to the conclusion that, only when robots own the independent and intrinsic thinking space as humans, could they have the prerequisites to be regarded as humans.

Robotics
Robots: the Century Past and the Century Ahead

Federico Pigozzi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2204.13331

IF: 3.7

2022-04-28

Robotics

Abstract:Let us reflect on the state of robotics. This year marks the $101$-st anniversary of R.U.R., a play by the writer Karel \v{C}apek, often credited with introducing the word "robot". The word used to refer to feudal forced labourers in Slavic languages. Indeed, it points to one key characteristic of robotic systems: they are mere slaves, have no rights, and execute our wills instruction by instruction, without asking anything in return. The relationship with us humans is commensalism; in biology, commensalism subsists between two symbiotic species when one species benefits from it (robots boost productivity for humans), while the other species neither benefits nor is harmed (can you really argue that robots benefit from simply functioning?). We then distinguish robots from "living machines", that is, machines infused with life. If living machines should ever become a reality, we would need to shift our relationship with them from commensalism to mutualism. The distinction is not subtle: we experience it every day with domesticated animals, that exchange serfdom for forage and protection. This is because life has evolved to resist any attempt at enslaving it; it is stubborn. In the path towards living machines, let us ask: what has been achieved by robotics in the last $100$ years? What is left to accomplish in the next $100$ years? For us, the answers boil down to three words: juice, need (or death), and embodiment, as we shall see in the following.
By the time we build robots that care for us, will we be able to care for them?

Robin R. Murphy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/scirobotics.abj9789

IF: 25

2021-09-29

Science Robotics

Abstract:Klara and the Sun by Kazuo Ishiguro is reviewed.

robotics
Between Man and Machine: A Posthumanist Analysis of I, Robot

Zhili Ding

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/b1p5ar74

2024-04-27

Abstract:In Isaac Asimov’s groundbreaking anthology, I, Robot, the intricacies of human and robotic interactions take center stage, delving deep into questions of consciousness, right, morality. Characterized by Asimov’s unique blend of science fiction and philosophical pondering, the stories establish a framework to reflect on the evolving dynamics of an advanced technological society in space. Robots are capable to interact with human, to interpret complicate orders and act automatically, to help human with dull or dangerous works such as calculating and mining, even replacing the workers. Asimov also raised Three Laws of Robotics to make sure that all robots function in order. Through the lens of posthumanism, the anthology is examined for its portrayal of the blurred boundaries between human and artificial intelligences. Robots and human co-exist in the society. However, due to the limitation of “Three Laws of Robotics”, some logical contradictions inevitably appears and lead to the dysfunction of robots. As a result, I, Robot emerges as a poignant critique of humanity’s ethical and existential challenges in the face of rapid technological advancements. Building on existing research, this article attempts to forge a new perspective by reflecting on the broader implications of the artificial intelligence in Asimov’s works through the lens of post-humanism. It considers the existential questions of AI on a consciousness level, explores the egalitarian relationship between humans and machines from a rights perspective, and analyzes the concepts of “humanity” and “human-like” from a moral and ethical standpoint. It encourages readers to recognize that robots are not mere slaves to humans; instead, humans should view AI with equality and reverence towards the advancements of the era’s technology. Humanity should step away from anthropocentrism, not solely viewing humans as the measure of all things in this rapidly evolving era of AI, and properly handle the relationship between humans and non-humans. Currently, with rapid advancements in science and technology, the world of human-machine coexistence depicted by Isaac Asimov is increasingly becoming a reality. The emergence of artificial intelligences like AlphaGo and ChatGPT constantly reminds us of the advent of a post-human era. This article aims to examine the connections between AI and humans, discussing the dynamic interaction and mutual shaping between robots and human society. This article hopes to provide new thoughts and strategies for understanding and addressing the challenges brought by the age of artificial intelligence.
Falling in love with machine: emotive potentials between human and robots in science fiction and reality

Anfeng Sheng,Fei Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11059-022-00664-8

2022-11-16

Neohelicon

Abstract:The rapid development of robotics and artificial intelligence (AI) has dramatically changed human society, facilitating travels and interactions worldwide and, in the meanwhile, increasingly propelling human beings to withdraw to their own worlds. It is foreseeable that humans are likely to become growingly dependent on robots to fulfill psychological and emotional needs. In real scientific world, scientists and engineers in America, Japan, South Korea, China and elsewhere are making increasingly smarter robots (or cyborgs) capable of understanding and expressing human senses and emotions. In the ever cyborgized era of posthumanism, the dividing line between human and robot is becoming blurred. We have to rethink humans' position in the world, to reassess the harmful idea of anthropocentrism and to learn to live with non-human in a symbiotic relationship. Technologies such as voice recognition, facial recognition and deep learning all accelerate the socialization of robots that show personal characters. This article focuses on the representations of human-robot emotions and emotional communications in recent science fictions and science fiction (SF) movies to explore how this relationship is imagined as a means to reflect on the ethical and technological challenges of this controversial issue both in fictional and real lives. This article also discusses the possibility of emotional/affective robots in the future, probing into the complicated entanglement of humanity and post-humanity.

English Else
Robots as Actors in a Film: No War, A Robot Story

Andreagiovanni Reina,Viktor Ioannou,Junjin Chen,Lu Lu,Charles Kent,James A. R. Marshall

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1910.12294

2019-10-28

Abstract:Will the Third World War be fought by robots? This short film is a light-hearted comedy that aims to trigger an interesting discussion and reflexion on the terrifying killer-robot stories that increasingly fill us with dread when we read the news headlines. The fictional scenario takes inspiration from current scientific research and describes a future where robots are asked by humans to join the war. Robots are divided, sparking protests in robot society... will robots join the conflict or will they refuse to be employed in human warfare? Food for thought for engineers, roboticists and anyone imagining what the upcoming robot revolution could look like. We let robots pop on camera to tell a story, taking on the role of actors playing in the film, instructed through code on how to "act" for each scene.

Robotics,Artificial Intelligence
Have You Ever Seen a Robot? An Analysis of Children's Drawings Between Technology and Science Fiction

Christian Giang,Loredana Addimando,Luca Botturi,Lucio Negrini,Alessandro Giusti,Alberto Piatti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41979-023-00098-6

Abstract:Technologies have become an essential part of the daily life of our children. Consequently, artifacts that imply the early adoption of abstract thinking affect the imagination of children and young people in relation to the world of technology, now much more than they did in the past. With the emerging importance of robots in many aspects of our everyday lives, the goal of this study is to investigate which mental representations children have about robots. To this end, drawings from 104 children aged between 7 and 12 years old were used as a map of representations, considering the drawings as a proxy capable of evoking learned or emerging mental frameworks. The drawings were analyzed in several steps: they were first labeled using binary descriptors and then classified using clustering methods based on Hamming distances between drawings. Finally, questionnaire items covering children's perceptions about robots were analyzed for each of the resulting cluster separately to identify differences between them. The results show that there are relationships between the way children draw robots and their perception about robots' capabilities as well as their aspirations to pursue a career in science. These findings can provide meaningful insights into how to design educational robots and learning activities for children to learn with and about robots.
Fiction meets fact: exploring human-machine convergence in today’s cinematographic culture

Christoph Endres,Frederic Frieß,Isabella Hermann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/icom-2024-0012

2024-05-16

i-com

Abstract:Abstract This article explores the theme of human-machine convergence as portrayed in modern science fiction movies and TV/streaming series and compares them to real-world advancements in robotics, artificial intelligence (AI), and virtual reality (VR). It examines how science fiction often depicts humanoid robots and AI with human-like emotions and intentions, contrasting with the actual technological challenges and ethical considerations in developing intelligent machines. The text discusses the evolution of humanoid robots from fictional portrayals to real-life examples like Boston Dynamics’ Atlas and Tesla’s Optimus. The paper also explores the reverse interaction, where humans become avatars in virtual worlds, and briefly discusses the ethical implications of simulating deceased individuals in digital form. Through this examination, the paper emphasizes the complexity of human-machine convergence and the importance of considering social, ethical, and emotional aspects in technological progress. It concludes by suggesting that while science fiction provides insights into societal fears and hopes regarding technology and thus into ethical and regulative necessities, the real trajectory of human-machine convergence cannot be predicted through film but will be determined by ongoing and after all incidental developments in the real world.

Computer Science,Philosophy
Debunking Robot Rights Metaphysically, Ethically, and Legally

Abeba Birhane,Jelle van Dijk,Frank Pasquale

2024-04-16

Abstract:In this work we challenge arguments for robot rights on metaphysical, ethical and legal grounds. Metaphysically, we argue that machines are not the kinds of things that may be denied or granted rights. Building on theories of phenomenology and post-Cartesian approaches to cognitive science, we ground our position in the lived reality of actual humans in an increasingly ubiquitously connected, controlled, digitized, and surveilled society. Ethically, we argue that, given machines current and potential harms to the most marginalized in society, limits on (rather than rights for) machines should be at the centre of current AI ethics debate. From a legal perspective, the best analogy to robot rights is not human rights but corporate rights, a highly controversial concept whose most important effect has been the undermining of worker, consumer, and voter rights by advancing the power of capital to exercise outsized influence on politics and law. The idea of robot rights, we conclude, acts as a smoke screen, allowing theorists and futurists to fantasize about benevolently sentient machines with unalterable needs and desires protected by law. While such fantasies have motivated fascinating fiction and art, once they influence legal theory and practice articulating the scope of rights claims, they threaten to immunize from legal accountability the current AI and robotics that is fuelling surveillance capitalism, accelerating environmental destruction, and entrenching injustice and human suffering.

Computers and Society
Ironies of social robotics

Tom Ziemke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/scirobotics.adq6387

IF: 25

2024-06-27

Science Robotics

Abstract:Aiming for "humanlike" or "natural" interactions can make social robots and their limitations more difficult to understand.

robotics
Behaving as or behaving as if? Children's conceptions of personified robots and the emergence of a new ontological category

Rachel L Severson,Stephanie M Carlson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neunet.2010.08.014

Abstract:Imagining another's perspective is an achievement in social cognition and underlies empathic concern and moral regard. Imagination is also within the realm of fantasy, and may take the form of imaginary play in children and imaginative production in adults. Yet, an interesting and provocative question emerges in the case of personified robots: How do people conceive of life-like robots? Do people imagine about robots' experiences? If so, do these imaginings reflect their actual or pretend beliefs about robots? The answers to these questions bear on the possibility that personified robots represent the emergence of a new ontological category. We draw on simulation theory as a framework for imagining others' internal states as well as a means for imaginative play. We then turn to the literature on people's and, in particular, children's conceptions of personified technologies and raise the question of the veracity of children's beliefs about personified robots (i.e., are they behaving as or behaving as if?). Finally, we consider the suggestion that such personified technologies represent the emergence of a new ontological category and offer some suggestions for future research in this important emerging area of social cognition.
Robots at work: People prefer-and forgive-service robots with perceived feelings

Kai Chi Yam,Yochanan E Bigman,Pok Man Tang,Remus Ilies,David De Cremer,Harold Soh,Kurt Gray

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000834

Abstract:Organizations are increasingly relying on service robots to improve efficiency, but these robots often make mistakes, which can aggravate customers and negatively affect organizations. How can organizations mitigate the frontline impact of these robotic blunders? Drawing from theories of anthropomorphism and mind perception, we propose that people evaluate service robots more positively when they are anthropomorphized and seem more humanlike-capable of both agency (the ability to think) and experience (the ability to feel). We further propose that in the face of robot service failures, increased perceptions of experience should attenuate the negative effects of service failures, whereas increased perceptions of agency should amplify the negative effects of service failures on customer satisfaction. In a field study conducted in the world's first robot-staffed hotel (Study 1), we find that anthropomorphism generally leads to higher customer satisfaction and that perceived experience, but not agency, mediates this effect. Perceived experience (but not agency) also interacts with robot service failures to predict customer satisfaction such that high levels of perceived experience attenuate the negative impacts of service failures on customer satisfaction. We replicate these results in a lab experiment with a service robot (Study 2). Theoretical and practical implications are discussed. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2021 APA, all rights reserved).

What will robots think of us?

Would robots really bother with a bloody uprising?

Robot Be Good

Reflecting on the Presence of Science Fiction Robots in Computing Literature

Early science fiction got microbots surprisingly right

Robotics and Artificial Intelligence [From the Editor's Desk]

Why robots should be technical: Correcting mental models through technical architecture concepts

A fictional history of robotics features forgotten real-world robots

A Short History of the Perception of Robots and Automata from Antiquity to Modern Times

Could robots be regarded as humans in future?

Robots: the Century Past and the Century Ahead

By the time we build robots that care for us, will we be able to care for them?

Between Man and Machine: A Posthumanist Analysis of I, Robot

Falling in love with machine: emotive potentials between human and robots in science fiction and reality

Robots as Actors in a Film: No War, A Robot Story

Have You Ever Seen a Robot? An Analysis of Children's Drawings Between Technology and Science Fiction

Fiction meets fact: exploring human-machine convergence in today’s cinematographic culture

Debunking Robot Rights Metaphysically, Ethically, and Legally

Ironies of social robotics

Behaving as or behaving as if? Children's conceptions of personified robots and the emergence of a new ontological category

Robots at work: People prefer-and forgive-service robots with perceived feelings