A molecular analysis of the evolutionary history of mushroom corals (Scleractinia: Fungiidae) and its consequences for taxonomic classification

A. Gittenberger,B. Hoeksema,B. Reijnen
Abstract:DNA samples from fungiid corals were used to reconstruct the phylogeny of the Fungiidae (Scleractinia), based on the markers COI and ITS I & II. In some cases coral DNA was isolated and sequenced from parasitic gastropods that have eaten from their host corals, by using fungiid-specifi c primers. Even though the present molecular phylogeny reconstructions largely refl ect the one based on morphological characters by Hoeksema (1989), there are some distinct differences. Most of these are probably linked to parallel or convergent evolution. Most fungiid coral species live fi xed to the substrate in juvenile stage and become detached afterwards. A loss of this ability to become free-living, appears to have induced similar reversals independently in two fungiid species. These species express ancestral, plesiomorphic character states, known from the closest relatives of the Fungiidae, like encrusting and multistomatous growth forms. Consequently, they were both placed in the genus Lythophyllon by Hoeksema (1989). However, the present molecular analysis indicates that these species are not even closely related. Another discrepancy is formed by the separate positions of Ctenactis crassa, away from its congeners, in various cladograms that were based on either of the two markers. This may have been caused by one or more bottleneck events in the evolutionary history of that species, which resulted in a much faster average DNA mutation rate in Ctenactis crassa as compared to the other fungiid species. Furthermore, it was investigated whether the exclusion of intraspecifi cally variable base positions from molecular data sets might improve the phylogeny reconstruction. For COI and ITS I&II in fungiid corals this has three positive effects: (1) it raised the support values of most branches in the MrBayes, Parsimony and Neighbor Joining consensus trees, (2) it lowered the number of most parsimonious trees, and (3) it resulted in phylogeny reconstructions that more closely resemble the morphology-based cladograms. Apparently, the exclusion of intraspecifi c variation may give a more reliable result. Therefore, the present hypotheses about the evolutionary history of the fungiid corals are based on analyses of both the data sets with and without intraspecifi c variation.
Environmental Science,Biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?