Abstract:Background Every major federal regulation in the United States requires an economic analysis estimating its benefits and costs. Benefit-cost analyses related to regulations on formaldehyde exposure have not included asthma in part due to lack of clarity in the strength of the evidence. Objectives 1) To conduct a systematic review of evidence regarding human exposure to formaldehyde and diagnosis, signs, symptoms, exacerbations, or other measures of asthma in humans; and 2) quantify the annual economic benefit for decreases in formaldehyde exposure. Methods We developed and registered a protocol in PROSPERO (Record ID #38766, CRD 42016038766). We conducted a comprehensive search of articles published up to April 1, 2020. We evaluated potential risk of bias for included studies, identified a subset of studies to combine in a meta-analysis, and rated the overall quality and strength of the evidence. We quantified economics benefit to children from a decrease in formaldehyde exposure using assumptions consistent with EPA’s proposed formaldehyde rule. Results We screened 4,821 total references and identified 150 human studies that met inclusion criteria; of these, we focused on 90 studies reporting asthma status of all participants with quantified measures of formaldehyde directly relevant to our study question. Ten studies were combinable in a meta-analysis for childhood asthma diagnosis and five combinable for exacerbation of childhood asthma (wheezing and shortness of breath). Studies had low to probably-low risk of bias across most domains. A 10-μg/m 3 increase in formaldehyde exposure was associated with increased childhood asthma diagnosis (OR = 1.20, 95% CI: [1.02, 1.41]). We also found a positive association with exacerbation of childhood asthma (OR = 1.08, 95% CI: [0.92, 1.28]). The overall quality and strength of the evidence was rated as “moderate” quality and “sufficient” for asthma diagnosis and asthma symptom exacerbation in both children and adults. We estimated that EPA’s proposed rule on pressed wood products would result in 2,805 fewer asthma cases and total economic benefit of $210 million annually. Conclusion We concluded there was “sufficient evidence of toxicity” for associations between exposure to formaldehyde and asthma diagnosis and asthma symptoms in both children and adults. Our research documented that when exposures are ubiquitous, excluding health outcomes from benefit-cost analysis can underestimate the true benefits to health from environmental regulations.

Health effects of exposure to indoor formaldehyde in civil buildings: A systematic review and meta-analysis on the literature in the past 40 years

Indoor formaldehyde levels in residences, schools, and offices in China in the past 30 years: A systematic review

Health effects of exposure to indoor volatile organic compounds from 1980 to 2017: A systematic review and meta‐analysis

Health risk assessment from inhalation exposure to indoor formaldehyde: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Health Risk Assessment of Inhalation Exposure to Formaldehyde and Benzene in Newly Remodeled Buildings, Beijing

Influence of indoor formaldehyde pollution on respiratory system health in the urban area of Shenyang, China

Effects of Long-Term Exposure to Ambient Formaldehyde on Hypertension and Angina Pectoris Symptoms: Evidence From the WHO SAGE Cohort Study

Long-term Indoor Formaldehyde Variations and Health Risk Assessment in Chinese Urban Residences Following Renovation

Ambient Formaldehyde Concentrations in Summer in 30 Chinese Cities and Impacts on Air Cleaning of Built Environment

Seasonal and diurnal patterns of outdoor formaldehyde and impacts on indoor environments and health

Differential Health Effects of Constant Versus Intermittent Exposure to Formaldehyde in Mice: Implications for Building Ventilation Strategies

Study on Formaldehyde Heredity Toxicity in Indoor Environments of Recently Renovated Houses

Health Effects of Exposure to Indoor Semi-Volatile Organic Compounds in Chinese Building Environment: A Systematic Review

The relationship of residential formaldehyde pollution in 11 Chinese cities to schoolchildren pneumonia prevalence in actual living condition

Indoor formaldehyde concentrations in urban China: Preliminary study of some important influencing factors

Exposure to formaldehyde and asthma outcomes: A systematic review, meta-analysis, and economic assessment

Human exposure to formaldehyde and health risk assessment: a 46-year systematic literature review

Residential building materials: An important source of ambient formaldehyde in mainland China

A Comprehensive Literature Review on the Effects of Formaldehyde on the Upper Respiratory Tract

Outdoor Formaldehyde Matters and Substantially Impacts Indoor Formaldehyde Concentrations

An Investigation of Formaldehyde Concentration in Residences and the Development of a Model for the Prediction of Its Emission Rates