Quantitative risk estimation of CNG station by using fuzzy bayesian networks and consequence modeling

Behzad Abbasi Kharajou,Hassan Ahmadi,Masoud Rafiei,Saber Moradi Hanifi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-54842-y

IF: 4.6

2024-02-22

Scientific Reports

Abstract:As one of the potential explosions and inflammation, compressed natural gas (CNG) stations in urban areas cause irreparable losses and casualties. Estimating risk assessment in gas stress based on coherent uses can reduce accidents in urban areas. The purpose of the present study was to estimate a small risk estimation at one of the CNG multipurpose stations, LPG, using combined models of the Fuzzy Bayesian Network, Bow-tie Diagram, and consequence modeling. This study was conducted based on the basic and 25 intermediate events. This study formed a seven-person safety team to identify the primary events and build the Bow-tie diagram. Then, because of the lack of a proper database, fuzzy theory was used to determine the probability of significant events. Bayesian networks were drawn based on the Bow-tie model using GeNLe software. Finally, the main events of the two Bow-tie, Bayesian network modeling, and risk estimation were performed with the help of PHAST/SAFETI (V8.22). The geographical information system software was used to zone the explosion effects. The Risk assessment result showed that the social risks and the Bayesian network model are more than Bow-tie, and the Bow-tie diagram is unacceptable. Therefore, using incompatible land uses in the vicinity of the CNG stations gives rise to the effects of accident scenarios in particular residential and administrative land uses, which decision-makers and city managers should consider. Based on the findings of this study, the obtained results can be utilized to implement effective control measures. These measures encompass devising a response plan tailored to address specific emergency conditions and conducting comprehensive training programs for the individuals and residents residing within the study area.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to address the quantitative assessment of the explosion risk of Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) stations in urban areas. Due to the potential irreversible losses and casualties caused by CNG station explosions, researchers utilized a combination model of Fuzzy Bayesian Network and consequence modeling to estimate the risk. They formed a seven-person safety team to identify key events and construct a bowtie diagram. Due to the lack of appropriate foundation data, researchers used fuzzy theory to determine the probabilities of key events. Then, based on the bowtie diagram model, a Bayesian network was drawn and risk estimation was carried out using the PHAST/SAFETI software. Geographic Information System software was used to assess the explosion impact zones.

The study found that the risk assessment results of societal risk and the Bayesian network model were higher than those of the bowtie diagram, and the risk assessment of the bowtie diagram was considered unacceptable. Therefore, incompatible land use near CNG stations would increase the impact of accident scenarios, especially on residential and administrative areas. Based on the research results, effective control measures can be formulated, such as customizing emergency response plans and providing comprehensive training to individuals and residents living in the study area.

The paper employs keywords such as Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA), Fault Tree Analysis (FFTA), bowtie diagram, Bayesian network, and CNG station. The background section discusses the issue of inappropriate land use in cities leading to hazardous events such as explosions. The risk assessment section introduces various methods including fuzzy bowtie diagram, Bayesian network, and consequence modeling. Finally, the risk is determined through modeling and sensitivity analysis, and recommendations for risk reduction are proposed.