Can we predict the predictability of high-impact weather events?

Austin A. Coleman,Brian C. Ancell,Craig S. Schwartz
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1175/mwr-d-23-0293.1
2024-09-14
Monthly Weather Review
Abstract:Ensemble sensitivity analysis (ESA) offers a computationally inexpensive way to diagnose sources of high-impact forecast feature uncertainty by relating a localized forecast phenomenon of interest (response function) back to early or initial forecast conditions (sensitivity variables). These information-rich diagnostic fields allow us to quantify the predictability characteristics of a specific forecast event. This work harnesses insights from a month-long dataset of ESA applied to convection-allowing model precipitation forecasts in the Central Plains of the US. Temporally-averaged and spatially-averaged sensitivity statistics are correlated with a variety of other metrics, such as skill, spread, and mean forecast precipitation accumulation. A high, but imperfect, correlation (0.81) between forecast precipitation and sensitivity is discovered. This quantity confirms the qualitatively known notion that while there is a connection between predictability and event magnitude, a high-end event does not necessarily entail a low predictability (high sensitivity) forecast. Flow regimes within this dataset are analyzed to see which patterns lend themselves to high and low predictability forecast scenarios. Finally, a novel metric known as the Error Growth Realization (EGR) Ratio is introduced. Derived by dividing the two mathematical formulations of ESA, this metric shows preliminary promise as a predictor of forecast skill prior to onset of a high-impact convective event. In essence, this research exemplifies the potential of ESA beyond its traditional use in case studies. By applying ESA to a broader dataset, we can glean valuable insight into the predictability of high-impact weather events, and in turn, work towards a collective baseline on what constitutes a high- or low-predictability event in the first place.
meteorology & atmospheric sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?