Abstract:Educational and Psychological Measurement, Ahead of Print. Thurstonian forced-choice modeling is considered to be a powerful new tool to estimate item and person parameters while simultaneously testing the model fit. This assessment approach is associated with the aim of reducing faking and other response tendencies that plague traditional self-report trait assessments. As a result of major recent methodological developments, the estimation of normative trait scores has become possible in addition to the computation of only ipsative scores. This opened up the important possibility of comparisons between individuals with forced-choice assessment procedures. With item response theory (IRT) methods, a multidimensional forced-choice (MFC) format has also been proposed to estimate individual scores. Customarily, items to assess different traits are presented in blocks, often triplets, in applications of the MFC, which is an efficient form of item presentation but also a simplification of the original models. The present study provides a comprehensive review of the present status of Thurstonian forced-choice models and their variants. Critical features of the current models, especially the block models, are identified and discussed. It is concluded that MFC modeling with item blocks is highly problematic and yields biased results. In particular, the often-recommended presentation of blocks with items that are keyed in different directions of a trait proves to be counterproductive considering the goal to reduce response tendencies. The consequences and implications of the highlighted issues are further discussed.

Theoretical and Empirical Comparisons between Two Models for Continuous Item Response

A Comparative Study of Item Response Theory Models for Mixed Discrete-Continuous Responses

When can categorical variables be treated as continuous? A comparison of robust continuous and categorical SEM estimation methods under suboptimal conditions.

Psychometric approaches for developing commensurate measures across independent studies: Traditional and new models.

Characteristic Function-Based Testing for Multifactor Continuous-Time Markov Models Via Nonparametric Regression

The InterModel Vigorish as a Lens for Understanding (and Quantifying) the Value of Item Response Models for Dichotomously Coded Items

Item Response Thresholds Models

Joint Maximum Likelihood Estimation for High-dimensional Exploratory Item Response Analysis

Modeling continuous response variables using ordinal regression

Three- and four-parameter item response model in factor analysis framework

Comparing item response theory models for ranking incorrect response options

Linear Factor Analytic Thurstonian Forced-Choice Models: Current Status and Issues

Joint Maximum Likelihood Estimation for High-Dimensional Exploratory Item Factor Analysis

Introducing Flexible Monotone Multiple Choice Item Response Theory Models and Bit Scales

A Computational Note on the Application of the Supplemented EM Algorithm to Item Response Models

Understanding Ability and Reliability Differences Measured with Count Items: The Distributional Regression Test Model and the Count Latent Regression Model

A Mixture Model for Random Responding Behavior in Forced-Choice Noncognitive Assessment: Implication and Application in Organizational Research

Modeling repeated self-reported outcome data: A continuous-time longitudinal Item Response Theory model

A GENERALIZED PARTIAL CREDIT MODEL: APPLICATION OF AN EM ALGORITHM

A Spectral Approach to Item Response Theory

Single-Item Versus Multiple-Item Measurement Scales: An Empirical Comparison