Towards Sustainable Rural Revitalization: A Multidimensional Evaluation of Rural Vitality in China's Traditional Villages

Anqiang Jia,Xin Yun,Xiaowen Zheng,Xuan Wen,Xiaoxu Liang,Yingxia Yun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16135408
IF: 3.9
2024-06-26
Sustainability
Abstract:Traditional villages constitute a significant component of China's rural heritage. In the context of national efforts to achieve sustainable rural revitalization, there is a lack of comprehensive assessments of rural vitality that can evaluate the balance between the competing demands of heritage conservation and rural development. This study addresses this gap by introducing an innovative evaluation index system, the rural vitality assessment (RVA). The RVA comprehensively evaluates both protective and developmental aspects while integrating natural and cultural ecological factors. This study leverages data from 206 traditional villages in Hebei Province and employs a hybrid model that combines subjective evaluations collected through interviews and questionnaires with spatial data analysis. This study shows that over 90% of traditional villages in Hebei Province exhibit an imbalance between protection and development, which could lead to gradual deactivation. Additionally, the spatial distribution of RVA outcomes shows polarization, with higher levels observed in the north and lower levels in the south. This study concludes that the RVA framework is an effective tool for analyzing the vitality level, spatial distribution, and disadvantage indicators of villages at different zoning levels. The results can provide a reference for the formulation of targeted heritage protection and development planning strategies and further aid in the rational allocation of resources, helping to narrow the development gap between urban and rural areas.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily aims to address the issue of sustainable revitalization of traditional Chinese villages, specifically focusing on how to comprehensively assess the vitality of these villages to balance the needs between heritage conservation and rural development. The study constructs an innovative evaluation index system—Rural Vitality Assessment (RVA)—to comprehensively evaluate the conservation and development status of traditional villages. The core contributions of the paper include: 1. **Construction of a multidimensional rural vitality evaluation index system**: This system includes six dimensions, namely rural industry, living environment, natural ecology, cultural ecology, development conditions, and development potential. This system considers the dual needs of rural heritage conservation and rural development. 2. **Adoption of a mixed model for evaluation**: Combining subjective evaluation (collected through interviews and questionnaires) and spatial data analysis for assessment. 3. **Empirical research**: Through data analysis of 206 traditional villages in Hebei Province, it was found that over 90% of traditional villages have an imbalance between conservation and development, which may lead to a gradual loss of vitality. Additionally, the spatial distribution of village vitality shows a polarization, with higher levels in the northern regions and lower levels in the southern regions. The research results indicate that the RVA framework is an effective tool for analyzing the vitality levels, spatial distribution, and adverse factor indicators of villages at different regional levels. These results can provide references for formulating targeted cultural heritage conservation and development planning strategies, help in the rational allocation of resources, and narrow the urban-rural development gap.