Children’s Education, Institutions of Learning, Technology and Wisdom Inquiry: Global Challenges and Methodological Perspectives
Giridhari Lal Pandit
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11406-019-00121-4
2019-12-03
Philosophia
Abstract:This paper is about the rationality of <em class="EmphasisTypeItalic">methodological variance</em>, where changes in method and methodology of science may be warranted/triggered by the urgency of finding alternatives to the methodology currently in fashion that <em class="EmphasisTypeItalic">fails</em> to address the relevant and pressing problems (Pandit <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR27">1983</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR31">1991</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR34">1996</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR37">2002a</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR38">b</a></span>; Pandit and Dosch <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR54">2013</a></span>). It deals obliquely with Maxwell's (<span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR14">2010</a></span>, pp. 667–690) <em class="EmphasisTypeItalic">criticisms</em> of Pandit (<span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR48">2010a</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR49">b</a></span>), offering only a bare sketch of appraisal of his methodological proposals of AOE, AOR and WI, not only as going <em class="EmphasisTypeItalic">beyond</em> SR but as better alternatives to dominant methodologies such as that of Karl R. Popper (<span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR66">1934</a></span>, 1945, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR67">1957</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR68">1959</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR69">1963</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR70">1969</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR71">1972</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR72">1974</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR73">1975</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR76">1977</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR74">1982a</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR74">1982b</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR74">1983</a></span> and <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR75">1994</a></span>), <em class="EmphasisTypeItalic">without</em> rehearsing or recycling Maxwell's well-known arguments in great detail (Maxwell <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR8">1974</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR10">2004</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR11">2005</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR12">2009a</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR13">2009b</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR14">2010</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR17">2014</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR18">2016a</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR19">b</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR22">2018</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR23">2019</a></span>). More importantly, how these proposals improve upon the eighteenth century Enlightenment idea of learning from scientific progress <em class="EmphasisTypeItalic">how</em> to achieve social/cultural progress towards an enlightened world (Maxwell <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR12">2009a</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR13">b</a></span>), i.e., a world that is sensitive to <em class="EmphasisTypeItalic">problems</em> of living and human well-being, is discussed. Having dealt with such problems in Pandit (<span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR33">1995</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR40">2005</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR41">2006a</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR42">b</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR43">2007a</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR44">b</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR45">c</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR46">2008</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR48">2010a</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR49">b</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR50">c</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR52">2012</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR53">2013</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR55">2014</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR56">2015</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR57">2016a</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR58">b</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR60">2017b</a></span>), the present appraisal is limited to <em class="EmphasisTypeItalic">the rationality of understanding, or better of rethinking</em>, <em class="EmphasisTypeItalic">academic inquiry within the wider contexts and reaches of wisdom inquiry</em>, with particular reference to the pressing global problems including those problems that are traceable to ETS progress, which is itself often found to violate the principle of interconnectedness across nature (Pandit <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR36">2001</a></span>, <span class="CitationRef"><a href="#CR42">2006b</a <p>-Abstract Truncated-</p>