A Strong Sustainability Framework for Digital Preservation of Cultural Heritage: Introducing the Eco-Sufficiency Perspective

L. Milios,Charlotte Fafet,Evangelia Paschalidou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/heritage5020058

2022-05-20

The Heritage

Abstract:The intensifying effects of climate change are becoming one of the main threats to cultural heritage, posing risks of degradation or destruction. Climate change is bringing complexity and uncertainty to ensuring the resilience of cultural heritage, and among risk mitigation measures digitalisation is regarded as a promising tool. However, the infrastructure required for the digitalisation process exerts significant pressures on the environment contributing to climate deterioration. To address these issues, this contribution developed a strong sustainability framework for the preservation of cultural heritage through digitalisation, for minimising environmental impacts and maximising the potential of preservation. To construct the framework, a literature review was conducted on efficiency and sufficiency concepts and existing approaches to sustainability of digitalisation in cultural heritage. To test the potential application and feasibility of the framework in driving environmental sustainability efforts within cultural heritage organisations, the case study of the Finnish Heritage Agency was analysed. The results showed that the understanding of the sustainability of digitalisation is not fully developed. Strong sustainability is hardly applied in practice, even though an inherent tendency for sufficiency especially in the appraisal stage was identified. It was highlighted that extensive stakeholder networks are required for advancing the sustainability of digital preservation. Ultimately, re-examining current practices and realigning stakeholders would be required for addressing the current challenges.

Environmental Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main issue this paper attempts to address is the threat to cultural heritage in the context of climate change and the environmental impact of its digital preservation process. Specifically:

1. **Threats to Cultural Heritage**: As the effects of climate change intensify, cultural heritage sites face the risk of physical damage or loss. For example, damage caused by extreme weather events (such as storms and floods) and long-term effects (such as rising sea levels and increasing temperatures).

2. **Environmental Challenges of Digital Preservation**: Although digitization is considered one of the effective tools for protecting cultural heritage, the required infrastructure (including hardware and software) can exert significant pressure on the environment and exacerbate climate change. For instance, the energy consumption of data centers and the handling of electronic waste both have negative impacts on the environment.

3. **Proposing a Strong Sustainability Framework**: To address the above challenges, the authors developed a strong sustainability framework aimed at minimizing the environmental impact of information and communication technology (ICT) through digital means while maximizing the potential for cultural heritage protection. This framework not only focuses on improving technological efficiency but also introduces the concept of ecological sufficiency, which involves reducing resource consumption while meeting basic needs.

4. **Case Study Validation**: The applicability and feasibility of this framework were tested through a case study analysis of the Finnish Heritage Agency. The results indicate that the current practice has not yet fully developed an understanding of digital sustainability, necessitating a reassessment of existing practices and realignment with stakeholders to address current challenges.

In summary, this paper aims to provide a new methodology for cultural heritage organizations, helping them to pay more attention to environmental protection and social responsibility in their digital preservation efforts.