HVAC Energy Cost Optimization for a Multizone Building via a Decentralized Approach

Yu Yang,Guoqiang Hu,Costas J. Spanos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/tase.2020.2983486

IF: 6.636

2020-10-01

IEEE Transactions on Automation Science and Engineering

Abstract:The control of heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC) systems has raised extensive attention due to their high energy consumption cost and operation patterns far from being energy-efficient. However, most of the existing methods suffer limitations in scalability and computational efficiency for large buildings due to the centralized structures. To compensate for such defects, this article studies the scalable control of multizone HVAC systems with the target to reduce energy cost while maintaining thermal comfort. In particular, the thermal couplings due to heat transfer among the adjacent zones are incorporated, which has been ignored or not well studied due to complexity in the literature. To overcome the computational challenges of the nonlinear and nonconvex problem caused by the complex system dynamics, this article proposes a decentralized approach composed of three main steps: 1) relaxing the bilinear system dynamics; 2) solving the relaxed problem in a decentralized manner using the accelerated distributed augmented Lagrangian (ADAL) method; and 3) recovering the recursive feasibility of the solution. Through a comparison with the centralized method, the suboptimality of this approach is demonstrated. In addition, the superior performance of this approach is illustrated through a comparison with the distributed token-based scheduling strategy (DTBSS). The numerical results imply that for buildings with a relatively small number of zones (less than 20), the two methods are competitive. However, for larger cases, the proposed approach performs better with a considerable reduction both in energy cost and computation time. Note to Practitioners—This article develops a scalable computing framework for multizone HVAC controller, which can help reduce the electricity cost while maintaining the comfortable temperature bands set by the occupants. The proposed computing paradigm is scalable to lar-e buildings as it mainly requires local zone-level computation. Specifically, for multizone buildings with a central shared HVAC system, the zone controllers determine the operations of their local variable air volume (VAV) boxes mainly through local computation and some necessary communications with the other entities. Consequently, this control technique can be implemented via local controllers deployed on simple hardware while applied to large buildings. The performance (electricity cost and computation time) of the controller is validated through a comparison with the centralized method and the DTBSS by using simulations.

automation & control systems

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to optimize the energy consumption of heating, ventilation and air - conditioning (HVAC) systems in multi - zone buildings through a decentralized method while maintaining thermal comfort. Specifically, in view of the scalability and computational efficiency problems of existing centralized control methods in large - scale buildings, the paper proposes a new decentralized control method, aiming to reduce energy costs and improve system performance. The paper pays special attention to the thermal coupling problem between adjacent zones, which is often ignored or improperly handled in previous studies due to its high complexity.

### Main Contributions
1. **Introduction of Auxiliary Decision Variables**: In order to deal with nonlinear and non - convex problems, the paper introduces some auxiliary decision variables to relax the bilinear system dynamics.
2. **Use of the Accelerated Distributed Augmented Lagrangian (ADAL) Method**: In the relaxed non - convex problem, the ADAL method is used to solve it in a decentralized manner.
3. **Recovery of Recursive Feasibility**: Through a proposed heuristic method, the recursive feasibility of the solution is recovered while ensuring satisfactory performance (energy cost and thermal comfort).

### Method Steps
1. **Relaxation of System Dynamics**: Auxiliary decision variables \( X_i^t \) and \( Y_t \) are introduced to transform the original problem into a more tractable form.
2. **Solution Using the ADAL Method**: The relaxed problem is solved in a decentralized framework through the ADAL method.
3. **Recovery of Recursive Feasibility**: The recursive feasibility of the solution is recovered through a heuristic method to ensure the effectiveness of the final solution in practical applications.

### Numerical Results
The paper verifies the performance of the proposed method by comparing it with the centralized method and the Distributed Token - Based Scheduling Strategy (DTBSS). The results show that:
- For smaller - scale buildings (with fewer than 20 zones), the performance of the proposed method is comparable to that of the DTBSS method, but it has a slight advantage in energy cost (a reduction of about 2% - 4%).
- For larger - scale buildings, the proposed method shows significant advantages in both energy cost and computation time.

### Conclusion
The paper proposes an effective decentralized control method, which is suitable for the optimization of HVAC systems in multi - zone buildings, can significantly reduce energy costs while maintaining thermal comfort, and has good scalability and computational efficiency.