Comment on: Penile prosthesis implantation is safe and effective in Peyronie's Disease patients with and without erectile dysfunction

Matthew Ziegelmann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41443-024-00977-5

2024-10-18

International Journal of Impotence Research

Abstract:Surgical options for Peyronie's Disease (PD) can be broadly broken down into three approaches: penile plication, plaque incision (partial excision) and grafting, and penile prosthesis (PP) with or without adjunctive straightening maneuvers [1]. Multiple factors influence the decision to pursue one approach over another. These factors include curvature severity, presence of indentation or hourglass, perceived and actual penile shortening, and baseline erectile function. For patients with underlying medication-refractory erectile dysfunction (ED), the surgical treatment of choice is likely PP with straightening maneuvers [2]. In contrast, patients without ED are candidates for plication or grafting without an implant, thereby maintaining spontaneous erectile function. In contrast to this classic surgical paradigm, Moncada et al. report their experience with PP for men with PD including in those with intact erectile function [3]. The authors identified 168 patients among five centers who opted for PP as first-line treatment for PD. The cohort included 33 patients (nearly 20%) without ED who opted for PP placement in lieu of other treatments. It was suggested that these patients had "significant or complex penile curvature", although the average curvature was 46 degrees and only 18% had hourglass deformity or narrowing. It was also suggested that patients without ED who elected PP were at higher risk for postoperative ED based on risk factors (older age, vasculopathy, etc.). Adjunctive maneuvers included modeling in the majority of patients (roughly 85%) and grafting in the other 15%. Importantly, patient-reported satisfaction rates based on a 5-point Likert scale were high in both patients with and without baseline ED (89 and 88%, respectively).

urology & nephrology