Is Removing 9 Lymph Nodes a Correct Cutoff to Define Optimal Lymphadenectomy?: The Open Question of Lymph Node Count

F. Tomao,L. Domenici,P. Panici
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/IGC.0000000000000225
2014-10-01
International Journal of Gynecologic Cancer
Abstract:To the Editor: W e read with great interest the paper published by van Beekhuizen et al1 titled ‘‘Lymph node count at inguinofemoral lymphadenectomy and groin recurrences in vulvar cancer.’’ This retrospective study showed that overall risk of groin recurrence after inguinofemoral lymphadenectomy (without nodal metastases), in patients with squamous cell carcinoma, is low (1.6% per groin). However, it significantly increases in patients with poorly differentiated tumors and lymph node count less than 9 at lymphadenectomy. Analyzing results reported by the authors, among 134 patients eligible for the analysis, in only 4 women groin recurrences occurred, with 1 developing contralateral metastasis, so that exclusively 3 of them were evaluated. In total, it is a very small sample, although significance was found, either at Kaplan-Meier analysis or at Cox proportional hazards model (both at univariate and multivariate analysis), even if confidence intervals were not reported. Moreover, van Beekhuizen et al did not report time to recurrence in this analysis. We think that this parameter could represent interesting data, considering that groin recurrence in those patients in whom the lymphadenectomy consisted in the removal of less than 9 lymph nodes might be associated to undetected nodal metastasis. Finally, most of the studies about lymphadenectomy differentiated the median number of resected nodes for bilateral and unilateral removal, reporting higher medians, overall in patients who underwent bilateral lymphadenectomy. Because these studies showed that a significant prognostic role was related to higher number of resected nodes at bilateral lymphadenectomy but with major medians of removed lymph nodes,2Y4 we think that in the study by van Beekhuizen et al, this value could have been altered by the analysis of survivals of both patients who underwent unilateral and bilateral lymphadenectomy. We strongly believe that inguinofemoral nodes count is a very important prognostic factor, both in bilateral and unilateral lymphadenectomy and in patients with either positive and negative nodes, so that further studies are needed to better establish parameters necessary to define optimal level of lymphadenectomy.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?