Abstract:The rapid and non-destructive monitoring of the canopy leaf nitrogen concentration (LNC) in crops is important for precise nitrogen (N) management. Nowadays, there is an urgent need to identify next-generation bio-physical variable retrieval algorithms that can be incorporated into an operational processing chain for hyperspectral satellite missions. We assessed six retrieval algorithms for estimating LNC from canopy reflectance of winter wheat in eight field experiments. These experiments represented variations in the N application rates, planting densities, ecological sites and cultivars and yielded a total of 821 samples from various places in Jiangsu, China over nine consecutive years. Based on the reflectance spectra and their first derivatives, six methods using different numbers of wavelengths were applied to construct predictive models for estimating wheat LNC, including continuum removal (CR), vegetation indices (VIs), stepwise multiple linear regression (SMLR), partial least squares regression (PLSR), artificial neural networks (ANNs), and support vector machines (SVMs). To assess the performance of these six methods, we provided a systematic evaluation of the estimation accuracies using the six metrics that were the coefficients of determination for the calibration (R2C) and validation (R2V) sets, the root mean square errors of prediction (RMSEP) for the calibration and validation sets, the ratio of prediction to deviation (RPD), the computational efficiency (CE) and the complexity level (CL). The following results were obtained: (1) For the VIs method, SAVI(R1200, R705) produced a more accurate estimation of the LNC than other indices, with R²C, R²V, RMSEP, RPD and CE values of 0.844, 0.795, 0.384, 2.005 and 0.10 min, respectively; (2) For the SMLR, PLSR, ANNs and SVMs methods, the SVMs using the first derivative canopy spectra (SVM-FDS) offered the best accuracy in terms of R²C, R²V, RMSEP, RPD, and CE, at 0.96, 0.78, 0.37, 2.02, and 21.17, respectively; (3) The PLSR-FDS, ANN-OS and SVM-FDS methods yield similar accuracies if the CE and CL are not considered, however, ANNs and SVMs performed better on calibration set than the validation set which indicate that we should take more caution with the two methods for over-fitting. Except PLS method, the performance for most methods did not enhance when the spectrum were operated by the first derivative. Moreover, the evaluation of the robustness demonstrates that SVM method may be better suited than the other methods to cope with potential confounding factors for most varieties, ecological site and growth stage; (4) The prediction accuracy was found to be higher when more wavelengths were used, though at the cost of a lower CE. The findings are of interest to the remote sensing community for the development of improved inversion schemes for hyperspectral applications concerning other types of vegetation. The examples provided in this paper may also serve to illustrate the advantages and shortcomings of empirical hyperspectral models for mapping important vegetation biophysical properties of other crops.

Estimating Leaf Nitrogen Accumulation Considering Vertical Heterogeneity Using Multiangular Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Remote Sensing in Wheat

A Comparative Assessment of Different Modeling Algorithms for Estimating Leaf Nitrogen Content in Winter Wheat Using Multispectral Images from an Unmanned Aerial Vehicle

Estimation of Nitrogen Nutrition Status in Winter Wheat from Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Based Multi-Angular Multispectral Imagery

Comparative Analysis Of Vegetation Indices, Non-Parametric And Physical Retrieval Methods For Monitoring Nitrogen In Wheat Using Uav-Based Multispectral Imagery

Estimating Leaf Nitrogen and Chlorophyll Content in Wheat by Correcting Canopy Structure Effect Through Multi-Angular Remote Sensing.

Monitoring of Nitrogen Indices in Wheat Leaves Based on the Integration of Spectral and Canopy Structure Information

Using Multi-Angular Hyperspectral Data to Estimate the Vertical Distribution of Leaf Chlorophyll Content in Wheat

Estimation of Winter Wheat Plant Nitrogen Concentration from UAV Hyperspectral Remote Sensing Combined with Machine Learning Methods

Combining UAV Multispectral Imagery and Ecological Factors to Estimate Leaf Nitrogen and Grain Protein Content of Wheat

An assessment of multi-view spectral information from UAV-based color-infrared images for improved estimation of nitrogen nutrition status in winter wheat

Estimating the Leaf Nitrogen Content with a New Feature Extracted from the Ultra-High Spectral and Spatial Resolution Images in Wheat.

Evaluation of Six Algorithms to Monitor Wheat Leaf Nitrogen Concentration

Leaf area index estimation model for UAV image hyperspectral data based on wavelength variable selection and machine learning methods

Estimating leaf nitrogen content by coupling a nitrogen allocation model with canopy reflectance

A Double-Layer Model for Improving the Estimation of Wheat Canopy Nitrogen Content from Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Multispectral Imagery

Wheat Growth Monitoring and Yield Estimation based on Multi-Rotor Unmanned Aerial Vehicle

Estimation of Paddy Rice Nitrogen Content and Accumulation Both at Leaf and Plant Levels from UAV Hyperspectral Imagery

Estimation of Vertical Leaf Nitrogen Distribution Within a Rice Canopy Based on Hyperspectral Data

Combining spectral and texture features of UAV hyperspectral images for leaf nitrogen content monitoring in winter wheat

Monitoring Leaf Nitrogen Status with Hyperspectral Reflectance in Wheat

Exploring Hyperspectral Bands and Estimation Indices for Leaf Nitrogen Accumulation in Wheat.