Abstract:Protonation is the most frequent adduct found in positive electrospray ionization collision-induced mass spectra (CID-MS/MS). In a parallel report Lee, J. J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2024, 10.1021/acs.jcim.4c00760, we developed a quantum chemistry framework to predict mass spectra by collision-induced dissociation molecular dynamics (CIDMD). As different protonation sites affect fragmentation pathways of a given molecule, the accuracy of predicting tandem mass spectra by CIDMD ultimately depends on the choice of its protomers. To investigate the impact of molecular protonation sites on MS/MS spectra, we compared CIDMD-predicted spectra to all available experimental MS/MS spectra by similarity matching. We probed 10 molecules with a total of 43 protomers, the largest study to date, including organic acids (sorbic acid, citramalic acid, itaconic acid, mesaconic acid, citraconic acid, and taurine) as well as aromatic amines including uracil, aniline, bufotenine, and psilocin. We demonstrated how different protomers can converge different fragmentation pathways to the same fragment ions but also may explain the presence of different fragment ions in experimental MS/MS spectra. For the first time, we used in silico MS/MS predictions to test the impact of solvents on proton affinities, comparing the gas phase and a mixture of acetonitrile/water (1:1). We also extended applications of in silico MS/MS predictions to investigate the impact of protonation sites on the energy barriers of isomerization between protomers via proton transfer. Despite our initial hypothesis that the thermodynamically most stable protomer should give the best match to the experiment, we found only weak inverse relationships between the calculated proton affinities and corresponding entropy similarities of experimental and CIDMD-predicted MS/MS spectra. CIDMD-predicted mechanistic details of fragmentation reaction pathways revealed a clear preference for specific protomer forms for several molecules. Overall, however, proton affinity was not a good predictor corresponding to the predicted CIDMD spectra. For example, for uracil, only one protomer predicted all experimental MS/MS fragment ions, but this protomer had neither the highest proton affinity nor the best MS/MS match score. Instead of proton affinity, the transfer of protons during the electrospray process from the initial protonation site (i.e., mobile proton model) better explains the differences between the thermodynamic rationale and experimental data. Protomers that undergo fragmentation with lower energy barriers have greater contributions to experimental MS/MS spectra than their thermodynamic Boltzmann populations would suggest. Hence, in silico predictions still need to calculate MS/MS spectra for multiple protomers, as the extent of distributions cannot be readily predicted.

Proton first: rationalizing a proton transfer in a protein-fragment complex

Protonation effects in protein-ligand complexes - a case study of endothiapepsin and pepstatin A with computational and experimental methods

Charge Interactions in a Highly Charge-depleted Protein

Proton-regulated electron transfers from tyrosine to tryptophan in proteins: through-bond mechanism versus long-range hopping mechanism.

Joint neutron crystallographic and NMR solution studies of Tyr residue ionization and hydrogen bonding: Implications for enzyme-mediated proton transfer

What Is the Protonation State of Proteins in Crystals? Insights from Constant pH Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Proton tunneling in benzoic acid crystals at intermediate temperatures: Nuclear magnetic resonance and neutron scattering studies

Transition from vehicle to Grotthuss proton transfer in a nanosized flask: Cryogenic ion spectroscopy of protonated p -aminobenzoic acid solvated with D 2 O

Protonation State-Induced Unfolding of Protein Secondary Structure in the Gas Phase

Application of classical molecular dynamics for evaluation of proton transfer mechanism on a protein

Quantum delocalization of protons in the hydrogen bond network of an enzyme active site

Capturing the Catalytic Proton of Dihydrofolate Reductase: Implications for General Acid–Base Catalysis

Double Proton Transfer in Hydrated Formic Acid Dimer: Interplay of Spatial Symmetry and Solvent-Generated Force on Reactivity

Impact of Protonation Sites on Collision-Induced Dissociation-MS/MS Using CIDMD Quantum Chemistry Modeling

Proton transfer reactions and hydrogen-bond networks in protein environments

Effect of histidine protonation state on ligand binding at the ATP-binding site of human protein kinase CK2

Identification of the protonation site of gaseous triglycine: the cis-peptide bond conformation as the global minimum.

On the dynamic nature of the transition state for protein-protein association as determined by double-mutant cycle analysis and simulation

Theoretical study of proton coupled electron transfer reaction in the light state of the AppA BLUF photoreceptor

Proton Affinity and Conformational Integrity of a 24-Atom Triazine Macrocycle across Physiologically Relevant pH

A Novel View of pH Titration in Biomolecules