Distract or Reappraise? The Mechanism of Cognitive Emotion Regulation Choice and Its Influential Factors
Ni Zhang,Kuo Zhang,Jingxin Wang,Xuechuan Sun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/PRBM.S389835
IF: 3.974
2022-12-16
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Ni Zhang, 1, 2 Kuo Zhang, 3 Jingxin Wang, 1, 4 Xuechuan Sun 5 1 Faculty of Psychology, Tianjin Normal University, Tianjin, People's Republic of China; 2 Mental Health Education for College Students, Weifang Medical University, Weifang, People's Republic of China; 3 Department of Social Psychology, Nankai University, Tianjin, People's Republic of China; 4 Academy of Psychology and Behavior, Tianjin Normal University, Tianjin, People's Republic of China; 5 Department of Information Engineering, Tianjin University of Commerce, Tianjin, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Kuo Zhang; Xuechuan Sun, Email ; Previous research on emotion regulation has focused more on the regulation effects corresponding to a particular emotion regulation strategy, yet the same regulation strategy may produce different regulation effects in different contexts. Similarly, one regulation strategy may not be applicable to all situations. Emotion regulation choice refers to the process by which individuals choose different regulation strategies in different contexts. Executive control and the level of engagement-disengagement considerations are the cognitive mechanisms of emotion regulation choice, while the neural mechanisms of emotion regulation choice still need to be explored more directly and deeply. Studies have found that affective, cognitive, and motivational factors have different degrees of influence on emotion regulation choice. However, there is still a lack of a reliable framework to systematically investigate the relationship between these influences and the outcome of their combined effect on emotion regulation choices. Future research needs to further explore the neurophysiological basis of emotion regulation choice by using different techniques and constructing a complete model based on multiple factors to more accurately grasp the dynamic process of emotion regulation choice. Keywords: emotion regulation choice, cognitive reappraisal, distraction, emotion regulation flexibility, cognitive flexibility Emotions affect people's lives all the time. Different emotion regulation strategies provide us with multiple means to cope with the effects of emotions. 1 Previous research on emotion regulation has focused more on the regulation effects corresponding to specific emotion regulation strategies, such as distraction being effective in reducing individuals' negative emotions in a short period, 2 while cognitive reappraisal is often associated with more positive interpersonal relationships, 3 higher levels of mental health. 4–6 However, studies have also suggested the opposite; for example, some studies have found that distraction is associated with lower well-being, more psychopathic symptoms, and lower social satisfaction. 7–9 Moreover, distractions do not produce adaptive outcomes in situations requiring long-term emotional regulation. 10 In addition, some researchers have found that the use of distraction has more adaptive effects than the use of cognitive reappraisal when dealing with stressful or traumatic events. This is because reappraisal consumes significant resources of self-control 2 and leads to greater activation of the sympathetic nervous system. 11 Thus, there is no absolute adaptive or non-adaptive emotion regulation strategy per se, 12,13 and the ability of individuals to make flexible emotion regulation choices in different situations plays a very important role in the effectiveness of emotion regulation. 13–15 In recent years, researchers have gradually shifted from focusing on the tendency and effectiveness of emotion regulation to paying more attention to the flexibility and adaptability of emotion regulation. 16 Choice behavior is a fundamental means by which individuals control their environment. 17 Emotion regulation choice refers to the act of autonomously choosing between different regulation strategies available in a given context. 18 According to the extended process model of emotion regulation, emotion regulation choice is in the second stage of the overall emotion regulation process. 19 It is important to emphasize that the choice stage included not only deciding which strategy to use, but also whether to regulate, 20 that is, the goal or intention of performing a particular behavior or obtaining a particular outcome. 21 Thus, the term "emotion regulation choice" represented how a person decided to work towards that goal or achieve the desired outcome. 22 However, there is still a lack of systematic research regarding the determinants and underlying mechanisms of emotion regulation choice. Therefore, this -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary