The Siphon Effect in Data-Driven Innovation of Government Hotlines?: A Comparative Study of Beijing and Shanghai

Xiaodong Zhang,Yihan Xiong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41111-024-00267-x

2024-01-01

Chinese Political Science Review

Abstract:This study provides a comparative analysis of the 12345 public service hotlines in Beijing and Shanghai, the two largest cities in China. Although similar in size, these cities have implemented distinct data-driven innovation strategies. Beijing has taken a more ambitious approach, marked by substantial resource allocation and increased departmental capacity. This strategy delegates decision-making and responsibility to grassroots governments while introducing a performance ranking system to incentivize local officials. In contrast, Shanghai has adopted a more moderate approach, integrating the hotline into its broader data-driven governance framework, characterized by greater flexibility and potential applicability to smaller cities across China. These findings suggest that ambitious data-driven innovation initiatives may result in a siphon effect in the citizen request handling process, where government departments channel additional responsibilities into the hotline, increasing its complexity and workload. This effect may hinder the hotline’s core function, especially for lower-level grassroots governments. Heightened top-down performance pressure could exacerbate this issue, potentially compromising the effectiveness of these services.