Temporal Precipitation Variation and Leaf Stoichiometric Changes Mediate the Dynamics of Tree Growth Responses to Nitrogen Addition over Time

Aijun Xing,Haihua Shen,Enzai Du,Longchao Xu,Mengying Zhao,Jingyun Fang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1029/2024jg008353
2024-01-01
Abstract:Nitrogen (N) addition can stimulate tree growth; however, the strength of this growth effect usually changes over time and the factors underlying these responses are not fully understood. Based on a decade-long N addition experiment (by adding 0, 20, 50, and 100 kg N ha-1 yr-1) in a boreal forest, we studied responses of tree growth to N addition over time and explored the potential role of temporal precipitation variation and plant stoichiometric changes in mediating this. We found positive growth responses to N addition but this effect changed nonlinearly over time. Annual precipitation was positively related to growth under high-level N addition; hence, a hump-shape temporal pattern in precipitation contributed to the nonlinear tree growth responses. After precipitation effects were accounted for, the positive growth responses to N addition peaked in the seventh year and then declined for all levels of N. Later reductions in growth responses could partly be attributed to increased leaf N:phosphorus (P) ratio over time, especially at higher N addition rates. We also found an increase in soil acid phosphatase, the ratio of labile to occluded soil P fraction, and a decreased ratio in leaf N to P resorption efficiency with increasing N addition rates during the late stage of this experiment, suggesting increased P demand. Collectively, our results imply that changes in plant nutrient stoichiometry with cumulative N input may limit the N stimulation on tree growth over time, while temporal precipitation variation appears unlikely to modulate this effect under the atmospheric N deposition. Tree growth can be limited by the availability of nitrogen (N), while the stimulation effects of increased N input on growth can change over time due to constraints by the availability of either water or other nutrients such as phosphorus (P). We investigated the temporal dynamics of tree growth to decade-long N addition in a boreal forest and assessed how growth was mediated by temporal precipitation variation and plant tissue N:P. The rate of tree growth was enhanced by N addition, but the positive effect first increased but then decreased over time. Annual precipitation variation mediated the growth response to the highest N addition (100 kg N ha-1 yr-1) only, whereas an increase in leaf N:P ratio over time under N addition explained the changes in tree growth response to N addition. We also found evidence for the acceleration of ecosystem P cycling. Our findings suggest that the relative P limitation may constrain tree growth responses to increased N availability over time, and these should be considered in predicting forest carbon sequestration with N deposition. Effects of N addition on tree growth changed nonlinearly over time Interannual precipitation enhanced the stimulation effect of N addition on tree growth under the highest N level only The increase in leaf N:P ratio over time mediated the temporal dynamics of tree growth responses to N addition
What problem does this paper attempt to address?