Machine Learning in X-ray Scattering for Materials Discovery and Characterization

Juan-Pablo Correa-Baena,Connor Davel,Nazanin Bassiri-Gharb

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-x8fx0

2024-10-21

Abstract:X-ray diffraction (XRD) is an immediate and powerful characterization technique that provides detailed information on the lattice structure and long-range order in crystalline materials. In recent decades, the quality and quantity of available crystal structure data has exploded, in large part due to the advent of online crystal structure databases, increased use of in-situ and operando methodologies, and user-accessible beamlines. The new wealth of data has also spawned an increasing use of machine learning (ML) to either construct high-throughput surrogates of established analysis or extract patterns from large datasets. However, XRD spectroscopy has been for many years solved via Rietveld refinement, while most ML techniques are simply complex statistical evaluation methods that are physics-agnostic. The discrepancy between data analysis and the underlying physics can lead to incorrect conclusions and/or limit the wide-spread adoption of ML techniques. In this review, we bridge the gap between ML and XRD spectroscopy with an introduction designed both for new data scientists and experimentalists interested in problems related to ML-guided spectroscopy analysis. We cover how supervised ML methods are used to predict likely symmetries and phases in pure and mixed samples, including challenges related to experimental artifacts and model interpretation. We also review recent uses of unsupervised methods in the extraction of patterns hidden in high-dimensional data, such as in in-situ and microscopic studies. Finally, we discuss the importance of problem formulation, data transferability, and reporting with recent case studies and give various resources throughout to expedite the learning curve for readers new to XRD or ML. We advocate for greater scrutiny of ML methods, how they are presented in the literature, and how to conduct data-driven research responsibly.

Chemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems this paper attempts to address are:

With the development of modern science and technology, X-ray diffraction (XRD) technology is increasingly being used in material discovery and characterization, generating a large amount of data. However, traditional XRD data analysis methods such as Rietveld refinement, while powerful, struggle to cope with high-throughput experiments and large-scale datasets. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following issues:

1. **Data Volume Surge**: In recent years, the emergence of online crystal structure databases, the increase in in-situ and operational condition research methods, and the proliferation of user-accessible synchrotron sources have led to an explosive growth in the quantity and quality of available crystal structure data. This data growth has spurred the need for the increasing use of machine learning (ML) techniques to build high-throughput alternative analysis methods or to extract patterns from large datasets.

2. **Gap Between Physical and Data-Driven Methods**: Although XRD spectroscopy has been well addressed through Rietveld refinement methods, most ML techniques are merely complex statistical evaluation methods with little knowledge of physical principles. This discrepancy between data analysis methods and underlying physical principles can lead to erroneous conclusions or limit the widespread application of ML techniques.

3. **Challenges of High-Throughput Data Analysis**: The analysis of high-throughput experiments and large-scale datasets requires efficient methods. Existing XRD analysis tools, while powerful, still face bottlenecks when handling large amounts of data. How to quickly and accurately extract useful information from thousands of XRD spectra is an urgent problem to be solved.

4. **Data Quality and Availability**: Current ML models used for XRD symmetry classification face challenges in data quality and availability, especially when classifying space groups. Achieving high accuracy with powder XRD patterns alone is difficult.

In summary, this paper aims to bridge the gap between traditional XRD data analysis methods and modern big data processing techniques by introducing machine learning methods, thereby improving the efficiency and accuracy of high-throughput experimental data analysis.