On the Redox Mechanism of Methanol Carbonylation on the Dispersed ReOx/SiO2 Catalyst

Alexander V. Mironenko,Neil D. Tran
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-j50np-v2
2024-10-18
Abstract:Acetic acid is industrially produced by methanol carbonylation using Ir- or Rh-based homogeneous catalysts and a corrosive HI promoter. Recently, a heterogeneous catalyst with atomically dispersed ReO4 sites on an inert mesoporous SBA-15 support demonstrated high acetic acid yields and stability without the need for a promoter (Qi et al. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2020, 142, 14178). In this study, we investigate the reaction mechanisms of methanol carbonylation on monopodal -ORe(=O)3 sites using density functional theory calculations, natural bond orbital analysis, and the energetic span model. We find that the reduction of dispersed Re(VII) oxide by CO through an indirect mechanism is essential for catalyst activation. The C–C coupling of methyl and carbonyl ligands is favorable in both Re(V) and Re(III) complexes, with Re(III) being superior due to transition state stabilization by a metal-localized lone electron pair. The preceding C–O bond activation is favorable only on Re(V) and leads to a thermodynamic sink, posing challenges in interpreting the high carbonylation activity in terms of monopodal ReOx site catalysis. We hypothesize that multi-nuclear sites or more exotic ligand environments drive the cooperative reaction mechanism of selective carbonylation.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore the specific reaction mechanism of methanol carbonylation to acetic acid on the dispersed ReOx/SiO2 catalyst, especially its redox mechanism. Specifically, the research objectives include: 1. **Understand the activation mechanism of catalytic sites**: - Studies have shown that Re(VII) oxides must be reduced by CO through an indirect mechanism to activate the catalyst. This process is a key step in understanding the entire catalytic cycle. 2. **Explore the reaction path of the C - C coupling step**: - In Re(V) and Re(III) complexes, the C - C coupling step (i.e., the coupling of methyl and carbonyl ligands) is favorable, but Re(III) performs better because the lone pair of electrons localized on the metal stabilizes the transition state. 3. **Explain the relationship between C - O bond activation and subsequent reaction steps**: - The activation of the C - O bond is only favorable on Re(V) and will lead to a thermodynamic trap, which complicates the explanation of the catalytic action of the highly active single - footed ReOx sites. 4. **Propose the role of multinuclear sites or more complex ligand environments**: - The paper hypothesizes that in order to achieve an efficient carbonylation - selective reaction mechanism, multinuclear sites or more exotic ligand environments may be required to drive the cooperative reaction mechanism. ### Formula representation - **Gibbs free energy change**: $\Delta G$ - For example, when calculating the Gibbs free energy change during the reduction of OReO3 to OReO2, $\Delta G= + 0.2 \, \text{eV}$. - **Reaction energy diagram**: - Figure 2 shows the Gibbs free energy diagram of Re+7 being reduced by CO to form Re+5 and CO2, where the energy change of the reaction steps is expressed by the formula: \[ \text{MeOH} + \text{OReO}_3\rightarrow \text{FA} + \text{OReO}_2+ \text{H}_2\text{O} \] \[ \Delta G = + 0.95 \, \text{eV} \] ### Summary The paper conducts in - depth research on the methanol carbonylation reaction mechanism on the ReOx/SiO2 catalyst through methods such as density functional theory (DFT) calculations, natural bond orbital analysis (NBO), and the energy span model. The research reveals the importance of the reduction of Re(VII) sites for catalyst activation and discusses in detail the reaction paths in the C - C coupling step and the influence of Re sites in different oxidation states. Finally, the research points out that in order to better explain the high - efficiency catalytic performance, multinuclear sites or more complex ligand environments may need to be considered.